National News

Key juncture in Confederation, 150 years ago

Canada
Canada's first prime minister, Sir John A. Macdonald, is shown in an undated file photo. A key juncture in the road to Confederation happened 150 years ago this week involving Macdonald and Liberal Leader George Brown. THE CANADIAN PRESS/National Archive of Canada
— image credit:

By Jennifer Ditchburn, The Canadian Press

OTTAWA - The word coalition has become something of a bad word in Canadian federal politics, demonized during the last election by the Conservatives and rarely entertained in public by the opposition.

But 150 years ago this week, the surprise creation of a coalition between two bitter rivals was what helped pave the way towards Confederation.

In the spring of 1864, Liberal Leader George Brown and Liberal-Conservative Leader Sir John A. Macdonald were two men who could barely see eye-to-eye on anything in the legislative assembly of the united Canadas.

Brown, the strident voice of Canada West (Ontario) and editor of the Toronto Globe, had fought for a generation for representation by population. He seethed at the notion that francophone, Catholic Canada East (Quebec) could carry as much legislative weight as his more populous region.

Macdonald had managed to form governments by stitching together a power base with the help of George-Etienne Cartier's Bleus in Canada East, but his administrations kept collapsing.

Finally, in June 1864, Brown emerged from a cross-party constitutional committee study professing his support for a Canadian federation. It came at an auspicious time, because the government was falling again.

A back-room meeting of rival politicians ensued in Quebec City. Within less than a week, Brown had agreed to enter into a coalition with his nemesis.

"The arch-enemies John A. Macdonald and George Brown attempted to seize each other not by the hand but rather by the throat," historian Ged Martin wrote in 1995 of the deal.

Brown went on to became a cabinet minister in the so-called Great Coalition.

"Can it be in any shape an object of ambition to sit down in the same cabinet with gentlemen to whom you have been opposed for a lifetime." Brown said in a June 22 speech to the legislature, reprinted by MP James Young in his 1902 book.

"Nothing but the most stern sense of duty could have brought me into such a position."

Barbara Messamore, a history professor at the University of the Fraser Valley, says the Great Coalition shouldn't be viewed so much as a coming together, but of a breaking apart.

"The coalition wasn't about people overcoming partisan differences in their own political ideologies, those were essentially intact, it was just kind of a recognition you might say that some sort of systemic change had to be made, that there was just something unworkable about things as they were," said Messamore.

"It's very much a pragmatic arrangement, maybe that's the Canadian way."

That pragmatic arrangement in June 1864 left the new coalition government free to devise a proposal to bring to talks with Maritime provinces in Charlottetown in September.

The Charlottetown Conference was supposed to be about striking a Maritime Union, but the emboldened Canadians decided to crash the party with a broader vision. Their strategy worked, and the principle of confederation took hold.

We encourage an open exchange of ideas on this story's topic, but we ask you to follow our guidelines for respecting community standards. Personal attacks, inappropriate language, and off-topic comments may be removed, and comment privileges revoked, per our Terms of Use. Please see our FAQ if you have questions or concerns about using Facebook to comment.

You might like ...

Kist resigns as Pacific NorthWest LNG president; Progress Energy CEO acting president
 
Woman charged with concealing infants
 
ELECTION 2014: Osoyoos mayor admits sign incident factored into decision to retire
Annual Starlite Campaign will start with Judy’s Star
 
ELECTION 2015: Large pool of candidates to chose from in Penticton
 
Meet the mayoral candidates: 2014 battle a rematch of 2011 election
De Groot family outraged: Sister of dead Slocan suspect says police overreacted
 
Heart of Our City: Jasper Nolos gets reacquainted with home
 
B.C. pulls plug on power projects

Community Events, October 2014

Add an Event

Read the latest eEdition

Browse the print edition page by page, including stories and ads.

Oct 24 edition online now. Browse the archives.