Kelowna council opts for expanded park in South Pandosy

City council rejects a staff recommendation that would have seen Abbott Street realigned and potential park land carved off for sale.

Park proponent Joy Lambrick (right) hands Cynthia Hunter a sign reading I Want More Park prior to Kelowna council's debate on the future of a proposed waterfront park and associated devopment in the south Pandosy area of the city Monday.

Kelowna city council has finally found a compromise for development of a waterfront park in South Pandosy that most, if not all, can live with.

On Monday, council received a round of applause from a packed gallery as it rejected a staff recommendation to approve a development plan for 11 city-owned waterfront lots near the foot of Cedar Avenue that would have included creation of a 5,740 square-metre park.Instead, council opted for an alternate plan that calls for a park nearly twice that size.

And in doing so, council also dropped an associated proposal to sell two of the lots at the north end of the parcel to help pay for development of the park.

The key difference between the two plans is Abbott Street will not be realigned under the adopted proposal and as a result, will not cut the city owned properties in half.

That move would have allowed land on the east side of what was being called the new Abbott Parkway to be sold off for development.

“I’m super excited,” said Michael Neil, an area resident and Kelowna businessman who led the three-year effort to press the city to keep as much land as possible for the proposed waterfront park in South Pandosy. “I’m just so glad they (council) took the time to look at this,” he said.

With every councillor and the mayor speaking to the issue following a presentation from city staff—some twice—it was clear council was divided on the two options before them.

Known as “refined option one” and “refined option four,” the former originally included selling the two lots at the north end of the property to raise money to pay for the $4.9-million park.

The sale of the properties would have returned the city about $1.7 million, said a report to council.

The other option did not include selling any potential park land, instead carving off property the city already owns by realigning Abbott Street and allowing development on the east side of the new road while using the property on the west side, between the road and the lakeshore, as park.

The latter plan would have cost $4 million but according to city staff would have been more than offset by a return of about $4.4 million from the sale of land east of the new Abbott Parkway for development.

A three-day design workshop, known as a charrette, took place earlier this year and featured representatives of the public and several associated groups. Three of the four tables at the charrette favoured the realigned Abbott Street model.

But many members of the public who showed up to view the work of the charrette opposed realigning the road because they felt it would carve off land they felt should be used for park.

In debating the issue, city councillors stated their preferences for the two recommended options with the final vote on the smaller park option  going down 5-3. Mayor Walter Gray, and Couns. Luke Stake and Gail Given voted for the smaller park option, while Couns. Andre Blanleil, Colin Basran, Mohini Singh, Gerry Zimmerman and Maxine DeHart voted against it.

Coun. Robert Hobson, who lives in the area, excused himself because of a conflict of interest and did not take part in the discussion or the vote.

In supporting the bigger park option, Blanleil and Basran both said a potential hotel that could be built on an adjoining piece of privately owned property will not be as intrusive on the park as some may feel.

And they said putting a road between it and the waterfront park would mean it would not be a waterfront hotel.

They, along with Singh, both said they wanted to see the city build as big a park as possible, one that will attract people to the waterfront in the area.

The proposed new park will link two smaller existing parks Abbott and Wall—at the north and south ends respectively.

The 11 city owned properties are located on the lakeshore just east of the South Pandosy commercial area.

When Zimmermann said he was not in favour of carving any land off for development, the standing room only crowd in the galley at city hall applauded, prompting the mayor to tell them it was “a meeting, not a rally.”

But that did not stop the crowd from applauding more as the debate went on.

Both Given and Stack questioned if the area square footage under the larger park option would in fact be nearly twice the size of the version staff had recommended, given the former included several “hard surface” areas such as roads, walkways and riparian areas.

Given also noted that three-quarters of the participants at the charrette seemed to opt for a plan that included realigning Abbott Street.

Like Stack, she also  felt the public may not feel comfortable using public property that appeared to be part of a hotel development.

But in the end, the vote was clear. After defeating Stack’s motion to accept the smaller park option,  a vote to approve the alternative, with an amendment that the two northern lots not be sold off, passed unanimously.

City staff will now come with a further report in late June or July refining the costs and laying out a time frame for work.

The work could be completed before the end of this council’s current mandate in December.

Without selling the two properties, the cost of new park could surpass $5.4 million, money that the city has not yet set aside.

Still, for those who have fought the city over the issue up until now, the outcome was seen as a victory.

“Now that’s a plan,” said area resident Joy Lambrick as she left council chambers smiling. “It’s been a long struggle.”

In 2011, the council of the day tried to present a plan for development of the land as both park and commercial development but strong public opposition scuttled that bid.

awaters@kelownacapnews.com

Correction:

This story, as previously reported, included incorrect information that has been changed. While the original story stated the vote on the smaller park option was defeated 5-3, the way council members voted was reported incorrectly. The correct tally was Mayor Walter Gray and Couns. Luke Stake and Gail Given voted for the smaller park option, while Couns. Andre Blanleil, Colin Basran, Mohini Singh, Gerry Zimmerman and Maxine DeHart voted against it.

 

 

Just Posted

Gas leak contained near Lakeshore Road

Ruptured line was quickly contained Sunday morning by Kelowna Fire Department

High winds cause havoc for sailors

Kelowna Fire Department assists boats with broken masts on Okanagan Lake

Late night confrontation between two men in Peachland

RCMP was called to the scene of a physcial encounter on Saturday evening where one man was injured

Search continues after human remains located

The search of the property in the 2200 block of Salmon River Road enters its fourth day

Kelowna hotel suffers water damage

Guests at the Royal Anne Hotel in Bernard were greeted by firefighters last night

VIDEO: Sears liquidation sales continue across B.C.

Sales are expected to continue into the New Year

10,000 signatures gained to stop ‘no pets’ rental policy

Pets OK BC said about 1,700 animals were surrendered to the BC SPCA last year due to housing issues

A golden opportunity

Orthodontist offers sweet deal for the pocketbook

Who is Curtis Sagmoen?

The Observer reveals what we know about the man attached to the Silver Creek property where human remains were found

VIDEO: Oprah Winfrey and a celebrities attend ‘B.C. Miracle Concert’

Fundraiser featured Foster, Steven Tyler, The Tenors, Matteo Bocelli, Laura Bretan, Carly Rae Jepsen

First-place Warriors edge Caps, visit ‘Backs today

West Kelowna scores twice in 25 seconds early in third to overtake Cowichan Valley in BCHL action

Grab a book; thank your librarian

All libraries are cornerstones of their communities and we celebrate them during library month

Five decades of volunteering

Even though she is approaching 70, Merle kindred continues to volunteer around the world

Twarynski trick sends Rockets past ‘Hawks

Rockets end five-game winless streak with victory Friday over Portland

Most Read