Letters to the Editor

Living subterranean while saving for a mortgage

To the editor:

Re: Secondary Suites Not Good For Single-Family Areas, June 26 Capital News.

I read this letter, that states secondary suites are “cancer” to single family neighbourhoods. The letter goes on to state the three major downsides to secondary suites are: More road traffic, higher real estate prices and city tax collectors collecting tax from landlords who rent out their secondary suites.

My partner and I live the subterranean lifestyle. That is—we live in a basement suite. I hold a university degree while my partner is a journeyman in his trade and we both are fully employed and make a middle-income.

We would love to live in a single-family home such as a small house or townhouse. The sad reality is that we cannot simply afford to rent an entire house to ourselves. Rather than get an additional roommate or two we have opted to rent within our means and as a result we live in someone’s basement suite.

This is a reality for many residents of the Okanagan. Regulation of secondary suites ensures that my partner and I, and many others like us, are not being taken for a ride.

I guarantee you that renters do not ask if the space they are renting is ‘legal’ if it means staying out of the elements and sleeping somewhere warm and relatively safe. This means that regulation of secondary suites is a great thing for renters looking for safe suites to rent.

I think the bigger issue here is how secondary suites help, especially when you consider how hard it is to find low-income housing in Kelowna. Wouldn’t you rather have that extra 1,000 sq. ft. of basement that you hardly ever use occupied by tenants rather than seeing it empty while people sleep on the streets, or in a shelter or on somebody’s couch? I know I would.

The traffic issue is paltry in my opinion. Perhaps a reform of public transportation in Kelowna may ease traffic issues but I think it will always be an issue regardless of the fact that your neighbour has tenants in his suite.

And as for the tax man: Maybe he can use some of the taxes collected from landlords to pay for better public transit?

I agree that secondary suites, when used as a mortgage helper, could possibly be raising mortgage prices. There is no way my partner and I could afford a single family home (in this sense, a detached home) without either having roommates or a secondary suite. We need to make more money or wait it out. And while we save up a hefty down payment we are left to consider ways to save up money. That means renting as cheaply as possible and that means hanging out ‘underground’ for a few more years.

Kim Larson,


We encourage an open exchange of ideas on this story's topic, but we ask you to follow our guidelines for respecting community standards. Personal attacks, inappropriate language, and off-topic comments may be removed, and comment privileges revoked, per our Terms of Use. Please see our FAQ if you have questions or concerns about using Facebook to comment.

You might like ...

Green MLA Weaver to seek leadership
New charter flight from Hamilton could bring steady stream of tourists to Okanagan Valley
Lake Country Food Bank project wins $100,000 contest
RCMP arrest three suspects
COLUMN: Cody cemetery gives up more secrets
Prince Rupert RCMP and emergency personnel march in honour of Const. David Wynn
New website exposes visitors to Penticton nude beach
Penticton bike trail plan rolls out to the public
Humble start for South Okanagan Crime Stoppers

Community Events, January 2015

Add an Event

Read the latest eEdition

Browse the print edition page by page, including stories and ads.

Jan 28 edition online now. Browse the archives.