Letters to the Editor

Different values applied to certified foods

To the editor:

I have worked as a senior organic inspector for over 20 years so let me address some of the issues about organic certification outlined in an Oct. 11 letter to the editor of the Capital News. (Organic Food Criticism Needs Scientific Backing.)

Answering three key questions:

1. Can organic certification be trusted? Yes.

2. Is Chinese organic (certification) meeting consumer expectations? No, not yet.

3. Do all organic certifying bodies follow the  same standards? Yes, but…

Organic certification is the gold standard of agri-food production around the world and at three per cent of total food sales, is still worth $60 billion and growing at seven per cent a year.

It deserves a premium over local or natural because it provides food with superior perceived and actual benefits.

The same cannot be said for industrial food with its regular recalls, food-caused illnesses and consumer deaths.

China follows the same paper standards as Canada, but here the Canadian Food Inspection Agency has oversight of the organic certification process, whereas in China other government agencies without the same enforcement powers oversee the process.

The following articles provide details about the frequent pesticide contamination of Chinese organic food:

• Western countries say “NO” to Chinese organic food, Li Ping, July 29, 2011, theepochtimes.com

• Can you trust organic produce from China, Deborah Kota, Dec. 14, 2011, bostonglobe.com

• Questions remain about organic foods grown in China, Jan. 7. 2012, seattletimes.com.

All organic certification bodies (CBs) follow similar production guides and materials lists. But how national programs are supported depends on the country, as we have seen with China.

Some CBs are just for profit, focus on mega corporations for the export market and are at the organic-as-industry extreme of the organic community. They push the limits for money until consumer groups complain and governments step in and some serious enforcement occurs.

I avoid the certifiers who do the biggest corporate organic players.

At the other end of the spectrum are the smaller CBs which focus on the local food market, are run by volunteers, try to educate consumers and transitioning farmers and are part of the organic-as-lifestyle end of the spectrum.

I buy all my food from local certified organic associations of B.C., accredited CBs and I try to stay regionally based.

Robert Dixon,

agricultural technologist,

senior organic inspector

Kelowna

We encourage an open exchange of ideas on this story's topic, but we ask you to follow our guidelines for respecting community standards. Personal attacks, inappropriate language, and off-topic comments may be removed, and comment privileges revoked, per our Terms of Use. Please see our FAQ if you have questions or concerns about using Facebook to comment.

You might like ...

Steele: Aquatic centre garden showcased
 
Peachland set to walk for dog guides
 
Okanagan artist showing in Coors Western Art Exhibition
COLUMN: Twin Peaks’ Kootenay/Boundary connections
 
Relive the David Thompson brigade this weekend in Rossland
 
Missing Andrew Evans
Skills upgrading for emergency responders
 
American trucker nabbed at Osoyoos border crossing with child porn
 
Transportation Minister revs up B.C. speed limit reform debate

Community Events, October 2014

Add an Event

Read the latest eEdition

Browse the print edition page by page, including stories and ads.

Oct 17 edition online now. Browse the archives.