Letters to the Editor

Letter: Will we be making reparations in future for today's laws?

To the editor:

I read Alistair Water’s column in Capital News of Jan. 14. [B.C. Should Do a Better Job at Apologizing Than the Feds.] He was championing the need for an apology and reparations to the Chinese community for the head tax in the 1800s.

I think an apology. and money reparation are wrong. You can’t apply today’s standards, to long ago actions.

The Chinese who paid the head tax knew the rules and chose to pay the price to live in this country. The law was made by the government of the day as authorized by the voters.

In the old days there were lots of rules like this. Non-whites could not immigrate to Australia until recently. White people could not immigrate to China and Japan and many other countries.

This is just the way it was, and just because it was wrong in modern day thinking, it was not wrong in the context at the time.

Canada executed killers in years gone by. We do not do it know. Should we now compensate the family members of these executed criminals?

If we re-think criminal incarceration in the future, should we compensate current prisoners?

Homosexual sex was illegal and persecuted in the past. Gay marriage was not allowed. Should we compensate all gay people for the injustices of the past, considered in the context of society now?

How about the white male applicants to the RCMP about 10 to 20 years ago, who were refused a chance to be an RCMP member, because the force would only take visible minorities and women. Should they be compensated for this discrimination?

How many laws and customs that we have now, in the future will be seen as discriminatory and wrong? Will society have to flagellate itself and pay for forgiveness?

Once again, you cannot apply today’s standards to right the happenings of another age.

Dave Lawrence,


PS: There is one wrong I would like addressed. Canadian citizens of Japanese origin during the Second World War, were taken from their homes on the coast and put into internment camps in the Okanagan. This was not wrong in the context of the day. What was wrong, was the government took their land, their houses, their boats and everything that was not accompanying them to the camps, and they sold it all and kept the money. No reparations were ever made for this theft.

And that pisses me off.





We encourage an open exchange of ideas on this story's topic, but we ask you to follow our guidelines for respecting community standards. Personal attacks, inappropriate language, and off-topic comments may be removed, and comment privileges revoked, per our Terms of Use. Please see our FAQ if you have questions or concerns about using Facebook to comment.

You might like ...

Green MLA Weaver to seek leadership
Lake Country Food Bank project wins $100,000 contest
OC students win international accounting case competition
Women well represented as Liberal candidates in upcoming federal election in the Okanagan
Annual Wine and Dine Thompson-Okanagan event kicks off
Wolf kill last hope for BC caribou herds
Community Market organizer sues Downtown Penticton Association
YPR terminal upgrades scheduled for summer completion
More than half of tested homes in Castlegar exceed radon threshold

Community Events, January 2015

Add an Event

Read the latest eEdition

Browse the print edition page by page, including stories and ads.

Jan 28 edition online now. Browse the archives.