Smithson: The ins and outs of moral damages a challenge for courts

Canadian courts have had something of a love-hate relationship with moral damages in wrongful dismissal cases.

Canadian courts seem to have had something of a love-hate relationship with so-called moral damages in wrongful dismissal cases.

I’d say that’s because the traditional damages for wrongful dismissal, based on the concept of pay in lieu of reasonable notice, don’t take account of the employer’s conduct.

The normal factors considered when awarding damages for wrongful dismissal include things like the individual’s age, tenure of employment, position and salary, level of managerial responsibility, and likely ability to find another job.

These factors are largely objective in nature and don’t account in any way for the employer’s conduct in the course of dismissal.

Yet, it’s an ongoing theme of wrongful dismissal claims that employees seek additional compensation as a result of the manner of dismissal.

Awarding damages in those circumstances seems to have proven to be a challenge for our courts—there has been a noticeable reluctance to embark on assessing employers’ conduct and assigning a dollar value to the resulting impact on fired employees.

A recent case heard in the B.C. Supreme Court laid out some of the factors to be considered in instances when fired employees claim an entitlement to moral damages.

Haftbaradaran was employed as the winemaker at St. Hubertus Estate Winery Ltd.  During a stressful harvest period, Haftbaradaran and his employer had what could be characterized as a workplace blow-up.

The circumstances were heated, Haftbaradaran was emotional and agitated, and the employer instructed him not to blow things out of proportion.  The employer asked Haftbaradaran to leave the office, he refused, and this led to him being called a “pain in the ass” and being told, forcefully, to get out of the office and get back to making wine.

Haftbaradaran broke down emotionally and, after the conversation continued, the employer suggested to him that perhaps he should go look for another job.

Haftbaradaran reacted by putting his keys on the desk, effectively inviting the employer to fire him, and walked out with the parting words, “good luck making wine.”

The employer took the view that Haftbaradaran had resigned and followed up with an email attempting to establish the date on which he would be leaving his employment. Haftbaradaran’s view was that St. Hubertus had terminated his employment.

Haftbaradaran sued for wrongful dismissal and the Court upheld his claim, finding that St. Hubertus effectively terminated the employment relationship with its email.

It awarded Haftbaradaran eight months’ wages in lieu of notice (which is definitely at the high end of the range for an employee with less than two years’ tenure).

The court rejected Haftbaradaran’s claim for “moral damages consequent to the manner by which his employment was terminated.”

It cited the Supreme Court of Canada’s 2008 decision involving Honda Canada Inc, for the premise that moral damages are only available when “the employer engages in conduct during the course of dismissal that is unfair or is in bad faith by being, for example, untruthful, misleading or unduly insensitive.”

In that 2008 decision, the Supreme Court of Canada stated that behaviour giving rise to moral damages might include “attacking the employee’s reputation by declarations made at the time of dismissal, misrepresentation regarding the reason for the decision, or dismissal meant to deprive the employee of a pension benefit or other right…”

The court could not find the conduct of St. Hubertus towards Haftbaradaran to be unfair or unduly sensitive.

Perhaps most importantly, the court found that moral damages should not flow from the employer’s “honest mistake” in believing that Haftbaradaran had resigned from his employment.

Haftbaradaran was unsuccessful in his claim for moral damages but the court’s comments provided useful guidance for employers in handling terminations in stressful, emotional circumstances.

Robert Smithson is a labour and employment lawyer, and operates Smithson Employment Law in Kelowna. This subject matter is provided for general informational purposes only and is not intended as legal advice.



Just Posted

Half-priced cat adoptions at the Kelowna SPCA

Adult cats are 50 per cent off until July 29 at the Kelowna shelter

Wildfire remains out of control near Lake Country

Lake Country - The fire started near Dee Lake, southwest of Coldstream yesterday

Kelowna RCMP investigating after woman finds a bullet in her car

The police believe it was an act of negligence

Waters: Can retired Kelowna top cop leave his old badge at the door?

Current and former Kelowna RCMP superintendents using different approaches to tackle downtown crime

Firefighters take to the roof of the Kelowna Yacht Club

Firefighters are supporting the The Bridge Youth & Family Services Society this weekend

Trudeau asks transport minister to tackle Greyhound’s western pullout

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says he’s asked Transport Minister Marc Garneau to find solutions in Greyhound Canada’s absence.

Vernon Knights hire Van Horlick

New head coach of Junior B franchise in Armstrong

St. Albert knocks down Canadians

Finals of Valley of the Champions

Restaurant Brands International to review policy over poaching employees

One of Canada’s largest fast-food company to review ‘no-poach’ franchise agreements

Calgary family’s vacation ends in tragedy on Texas highway

Three people died and four others were injured in the crash

Union construction cost competitive, B.C. Building Trades say

Non-union firms can bid on infrastructure, but employees have to join international unions

Arrows stick it to Adanacs

Vernon Men’s Baseball League playoff final

Trudeau to shuffle cabinet ahead of Liberals’ team for 2019

Trudeau could lighten the work loads of cabinet ministers who currently oversee more than one portfolio

Car calls 911 on possible impaired B.C. driver

A luxury car automatically calls Princeton police to scene of crash involving alcohol

Most Read