Defence lawyer in polygamy trial to launch charter challenge over evidence

Polygamy trial to hear charter challenge

CRANBROOK, B.C. — A lawyer for a Mormon fundamentalist leader says he will be seeking a stay of a polygamy charge because the evidence being used in the B.C. Supreme Court trial was already presented in a previous constitutional reference case.

Blair Suffredine, the defence counsel for Winston Blackmore, said he intends to file an application for abuse of process next week based on the Crown’s reliance on evidence that was collected before a constitutional reference test in 2011 that deemed polygamy a criminal offence.

Blackmore, the head of a religious group in the southeastern B.C. community of Bountiful, is accused of marrying 24 women.

Suffredine’s argument is based on a previous polygamy charge against Blackmore which was thrown out of court over allegations of “special prosecutor-shopping.”

In 2007, Richard Peck was appointed as a special prosecutor to examine evidence of polygamy that resulted from a police investigation into Blackmore and James Oler, who also served as a bishop in the fundamentalist community.

Peck declined to pursue charges based on the constitutional argument of religious freedom but recommended that a constitutional reference case be brought forward to test the criminality of polygamy.

Former attorney general Wally Oppal later appointed Terry Robertson to the case, who decided to move forward in prosecuting polygamy.

The charge was eventually thrown out, as well as Robertson’s appointment as a special prosecutor, on the grounds that Oppal had unfairly searched for a prosecutor willing to pursue charges when others had declined.

A constitutional reference case went forward with a ruling in 2011 that upheld laws criminalizing polygamy, determining it didn’t violate religious freedoms guaranteed in the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

Suffredine said his charter argument next week will rest on the fact that all evidence being presented at the current trial was collected before the constitutional reference case and cannot be used.

“What I’m saying is that this prosecution is all based on the old evidence that pre-dated the reference and no new evidence of anything else since the reference,” Suffredine said outside court Thursday. “Therefore, it is an unfair trial to now come back and prosecute them when nobody knew at the time whether they were committing any crime.”

At the start of the trial, Suffredine told the court he didn’t intend to file a charter challenge, but changed his mind as the proceedings went on and he saw the scope of the Crown’s evidence.

Suffredine’s intention to file notice follows a voir dire — a process to determine the admissibility of evidence — for statements Blackmore’s co-accused, Oler, made to police.

Justice Sheri Donegan will issue her voir dire ruling on Monday, before the Crown resumes its case.

“So then at that point, I’m going to argue the charter that this is an abuse of process because we now know what all the evidence is and we know it’s entirely based on events that preceded the reference,” Suffredine said. 

The trial is currently in its eighth day and has heard testimony from mainstream Mormon experts, law enforcement who worked on the investigation and Jane Blackmore, a former wife of Winston Blackmore who left the community in 2003.

(Cranbrook Townsman)

Trevor Crawley, Cranbrook Townsman, The Canadian Press

Canadian Press

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Morning Start: Hawaiian Pizza is Canadian

Your morning start for Monday, Sept. 28, 2020

UPDATE: One dead after motorcycle collision on Highway 97 near Peachland

The collision closed Highway 97 off-and-on throughout Sunday afternoon

Tree replacement, construction scheduled for Kelowna’s Stuart Park

Sixteen trees are being removed because they are struggling, the city said

Okanagan whisky lottery adds new twists

Winners of Okanagan Spirits’ Laird of Fintry lottery announced in four batches beginning Sept. 28

BC Libertarian party names Kelowna West candidate

Matt Badura has been acclaimed as Kelowna West’s Libertarian candidate in the upcoming provincial election

B.C. records 98 more COVID-19 cases, most in Lower Mainland

One new senior home outbreak, Surrey Memorial outbreak over

Canadian ski resorts wrestle with pandemic-vs.-profit dilemma as COVID-19 persists

Few are actually restricting the total number of skiers they allow on the hill

Three arrested after Keremeos shooting that severely injured one man

The victim was transported by air ambulance to a regional hospital

Is it time to start thinking about greener ways to package cannabis?

Packaging suppliers are still figuring eco-friendly and affordable packaging options that fit the mandates of Cannabis Regulations

Victoria-area RCMP locate high-risk sex offender thanks to help of taxi cab driver

Scott Jones wanted on a Canada-wide warrant, ‘a risk to women and girls,’ police say

Join Black Press Media and Do Some Good

Pay it Forward program supports local businesses in their community giving

A (virtual) walk around the world by 88-year-old B.C. man

George Doi says it’s simple: ‘I like walking’

End of CERB means uncertainty for some, new system for others

As of a week ago, the CERB had paid out $79.3 billion to 8.8 million people

West Kelowna Warriors complete sweep of Vernon Vipers

Warriors edge Snakes 2-1 as Okanagan Cup BCHL exhibition tournament begins

Most Read