Tegan and Sara join YouTubers in questioning LGBTQ video filtering

Tegan and Sara question YouTube hiding LGBTQ videos

HASH(0xb4be40)

TORONTO — A chorus of Canadian LGBTQ YouTubers, including pop duo Tegan and Sara, is calling for the video service to stop filtering out gay and trans-themed videos for some users.

The Calgary-raised sisters took to social media to question why YouTube’s “restricted” setting blocks a wide variety of LGBTQ-friendly content for no clear reason.

“If you put YouTube on restricted mode a bunch of our music videos disappear. I checked myself. LGBTQ people shouldn’t be restricted. SAD!” Tegan and Sara tweeted. Among the missing clips were videos from their latest album, including for “That Girl” and “U-turn.”

They were joined by Halifax singer Ria Mae, who said her video for “Gold,” which features the singer in a lesbian relationship, was also being filtered out.

“Young gay kids need to see themselves represented and they need to know it’s normal, it’s OK and it’s not X-rated,” Mae said in a video on her Instagram account.

“It sends a bad message to young gay kids and young trans kids that their lives are not normal or acceptable.”

At issue is YouTube’s “restricted” designation, which lets parents, schools and libraries filter content that may be considered inappropriate for users under 18. YouTube calls it “an optional feature used by a very small subset of users.”

What’s unclear is whether the types of videos in question are being labelled as “restricted” for the first time, or if this has been an ongoing practice that’s only recently gained attention.

Video producer Michael Rizzi, who’s based in Toronto, says he’s concerned with the message it sends to loyal YouTube users. He’s seen 176 of his 236 videos disappear in “restricted” mode, representing 75 per cent of the clips he’s uploaded over the past five years.

Rizzi says he wished Google’s YouTube executives would’ve been more transparent about how this happened. Instead, they appeared to sit back as YouTubers made the hashtag #YouTubeIsOverParty a trending topic on Twitter over the weekend.

“It’s more a feeling of being pushed to the side,” Rizzi says. “It’s a pretty big screw-up on their end.”

In an emailed statement on Monday, YouTube acknowledged the filter saying “some videos that cover subjects like health, politics and sexuality may not appear for users and institutions that choose to use this feature.”

YouTube added later that “some videos are incorrectly labelled by our automated system and we realize it’s very important to get this right.”

“We’re working hard to make some improvements,” the company said without offering further details.

The lack of information has left YouTubers struggling to determine what’s being sifted out, what isn’t and why it’s happening.

Rizzi suspects video tags like “LGBT” or “gay couple” may be triggering the filter for “7 Things I Love About My Boyfriend,” a video he says shouldn’t be restricted for a younger audience.

Even his clip commissioned for YouTube’s #ProudToBe campaign, timed to last year’s Pride Month, is now filtered out.

“YouTube’s own equality campaign is restricted, which is probably the weirdest part of everything,” Rizzi says.

Fellow YouTuber Stef Sanjati has seen about 20 per cent of her content — or 49 videos — filtered in the site’s “restricted” mode. She says the filter is hiding clips of her talking about transgender student bathrooms and makeup tutorials.

She hasn’t been able to figure out which keywords tagged to her videos might trigger the filter.

“The execution is so off the mark,” she says.

“It’s not about clicks and view counts. It’s about these resources being available for young people who would otherwise have no access to them.”

Sanjati vented her frustrations in a 10-minute YouTube video that’s been viewed more than 33,000 times. She hopes by speaking out, YouTube executives will understand how they’ve negatively impacted a loyal segment of their users.

“Restricting (these videos) is sending a message that we should discriminate against these people,” Sanjati says.

“I’m hearing, ‘I’m sorry you feel that way, we might fix it one day.’ And that’s not really enough for us. It feels very dismissive.”

 

Follow @dfriend on Twitter.

David Friend, The Canadian Press

Just Posted

Caught on Camera: Boat catches fire at Kelowna marina

The cause of the fire is unknown at this time, no injuries were reported as a result of the blaze

Kelowna Chiefs win in epic overtime battle in emotional memorial night to late owner

The Chiefs hounoured Grant Sheridan with a win in the team’s home-opener

West Kelowna’s stuggles continue as Warriors drop game in Merritt

The Warriors gave up a 2-0 lead to lose 4-2 Friday night

West Kelowna won’t get an urgent care centre says health minister

Adrian Dix says other options are being considered to improve health services on Westside

Climate protesters temporarily shut down Bernard Avenue in Kelowna

Protesters are demanding politicans take action to stop climate change

VIDEO: Grizzly bears fight along northern B.C. highway in rare footage

Cari McGillivray posted the head-turning video, shot near Stewart, B.C., to social media

Handgun crackdown, health spending and transit plans latest campaign promises

Friday was the end of a busy week on the campaign trail

B.C. woman photographs massive ant swarm on Abbotsford driveway

She asked what the ants were doing? The answer: war

Police arrest B.C. phone scammer linked to illegal call centres in India

Person arrested in Burnaby here on a work visa, says police

Air Canada forced girl, 12, to remove hijab: civil rights group

The San Francisco Bay Area office of the Council on American-Islamic Relations calling for change

Man from Winnipeg who was hiking alone found dead in Banff National Park

RCMP say the man was hiking alone on Mount Temple Thursday

Okanagan hosts Mexico for soccer

The Okanagan Masters League won both matches against their Mexican counterparts

Takaya, B.C.’s intriguing lone wolf, seen eating seal and howling away on Discovery Island

Fun facts about Takaya the wolf, like his a 36-hour tour around Chatham, Discovery Islands

Graffiti, calls and Snapchat: RCMP probe string of threats targeting Kamloops schools

There have been nine different threats made to four different schools in the city

Most Read