City Hall defends spending habits

Kelowna earned the dubious distinction of being one of this province’s biggest municipal spenders.

Kelowna earned the dubious distinction of being one of the province’s biggest municipal spenders in a Canadian Federation of Independent Businesses report released this week.

But those closest to the city’s books point out there’s more to the new rank than meets the eye.

Keith Grayston, the city’s director of finances, says the report that places Kelowna as the fourth worst spender in the province’s largest cities, doesn’t accurately reflect the demands on a municipal government.

“We’re always looking for opportunities to be more efficient or do things better, and in a lot of cases we run things similar to the way a business would,” said Grayston.

“But the difference is our social obligation and the requirement to provide services the private sector will not. A business would never run a pool, because there’s no profit to be had, but that’s something people expect from a municipal government.”

The federation relied on a simplistic formula that pits the rate of population growth, which was 22 per cent, against the growth of real operating spending.

In Kelowna’s case, real operating spending increased 76 per cent from 2000 to 2009, and that means per capita this city’s costs have increased by 45 per cent since the start of the decade.

“A number of things, have changed in the last 10 years, in terms of service levels,” said Grayston.

“Our transit system has increased the number of service hours quite substantially over the last 10 years, so any time we have an increase in service levels it will cause a cost increase beyond the factors they consider.”

This decade also brought new responsibilities to municipalities, which now have to foot the bill for a larger portion of affordable housing, social housing, police, not to mention new environmental regulations.

“When all tax payers sign on to reducing greenhouse gases, there’s costs associated with that,” he said.

“There are demands from all areas, but whenever we’ve done the citizen surveys we ask, ‘Would you like to reduce service levels to reduce tax levels?’”

To that, the response is always a resounding “no.”

“These reports are frustrating,” said Grayston, noting the city does everything it can to make its finances transparent.

“But this is one group putting their opinion forward, and we welcome the dialogue, just wish it wasn’t presented in the manner or mood it was.”

For its part, the federation said the report card shouldn’t be viewed as a personal attack.

It’s just a “neutral robotic stat-based measure of what’s happening,” Shachi Kurl, CFIB director of provincial affairs for B.C. and Yukon.

“Communities that rank well cheer this report, and communities who don’t, poo-poo the report,” said Kurl.

Regardless of their reaction, however, it is one way to hold communities accountable and get the tax payer thinking about what the federation believes to be are key questions before they head to the polls.

“They need to ask, ‘Am I getting 45 per cent more in services? Is my mayor and council keeping an eye on the bottom line, and am I satisfied?’ If the answers are ‘yes,’ and there are good explanations, then fine. It’s really just another look at what is really going on.”

The CFIB report also recommends municipalities support the creation of an independent municipal auditor-general.

Kurl said if there isn’t some sort of oversight, the tax payer only hears one voice, and that’s city representatives who sing their own praises.


Just Posted

Cherry season has arrived in the Okanagan

Dust off those cherry pie recipes

Sun-Rype Products Ltd. and Mamas for Mamas announce partnership

The partnership will help support mothers in crisis

Foundry Kelowna makes health care impact

More than 1,000 people ages 12 to 24 in the past year have come seeking help

Canadian pet boutique expands to Ontario

The Bone & Biscuit Company looks to leave it’s paw print

Two artists put on divine feminine art show in Kelowna

The show will be on for the month of July

Homeless people living on ‘Surrey Strip’ move into modular housing

BC Housing says 160 homeless people are being moved into temporary Whalley suites from June 19 to 21

Port of Prince Rupert names Shaun Stevenson as new CEO

Stevenson has worked for the port for 21 years as vice president of trade development

Senate officially passes Canada’s marijuana legalization bill

Bill C-45 now moves to royal assent, which is the final step in the legislative process

Fake attempted abduction not funny to B.C. neighbourhood residents

Two teenage boys won’t face criminal charges after scaring girl

New craft brewery location chosen in Kelowna

Rustic Reel Brewing says it will produce beer at new location on Vaughan Avenue

Mosquitoes out in full force already? Blame the weather

But a B.C. mosquito expert says the heat wave will help keep the pests at bay

Man pleads not guilty in 1987 slayings of B.C. couple

William Talbott of SeaTac was arraigned Tuesday in Snohomish County Superior Court

New GOP plan: Hold kids longer at border – but with parents

Move would ease rules that limit how much time minors can be held with their parents

Without a big data strategy, Canadians at risk of being ‘data cows’

Presentation said artificial intelligence could give Facebook and Amazon even more power

Most Read