Researchers

Researchers

Kelowna: UBCO economist and water stewardship members question ALR change

Agricultural Land Commission Amendment Act questioned in light of development pressure and climate change

  • May. 13, 2014 6:00 p.m.

The need to make any changes to the Agricultural Land Reserve and how it is governed is questionable, a local economist told the Okanagan Water Stewardship Council last Thursday.

UBCO professor John Janmatt says the controversial Agricultural Land Commission Amendment Act 2014 currently in the hands of agriculture minister Norm Letnick stirs a litany of questions.

“How broken is the current system and does it really need to be changed?” he asked in interview after his talk. “Are we suffering that much and, if there are these big glaring problems, lets see them rather than these simple little anecdotes of the odd person who doesn’t like it.”

The council is the technical advisory board for the Okanagan Basin Water Board. and offered many unique perspectives as members weighed in on the issue.

Janmatt’s presentation pointed out the amendments to the act do not address the concerns outlined in the Auditor General’s 2010 review of the ALC, which noted mapping of the reserve’s boundaries is weak and oversight of the “delegated authorities” needs strengthening.

Those delegated authorities include a couple of regional governments and the B.C. Oil and Gas Commission, which has been handling review of requests for boundary adjustments and removal of chunks of the ALR pertaining to the oil and gas industry since the mid-’90s.

The massive amount of legislative change in the province—the creation of the new Water Sustainability Act, the Parks Amendment Act, the Agricultural Land Commission amendments—is pegged by pundits as paving the way for oil and gas expansion, but Janmaat sees another culprit in the ALC amendments.

John Janmaat“Most of the applications come from municipalities and developers not from farmers,” he said. “So it’s not really about benefiting farm families, but it’s about enabling landowners to either get their land directly out of the ALR or at least to subdivide it or start new activities so they can get new activities out of the land.”

Grape grower Hans Buchler, a former director of the B.C. Agriculture Council and member of the council,  suggesting only six per cent of the applications that come to the ALC requesting variances and changes to the protective land reserve come from farmers.

Janmaat’s presentation mapped the lands removed and added to the ALR in this province, and the results clearly indicated land is being taken out in the Kootenays, along the border where wealthy Calgarians might want to shop for small estate lands, and in pricey Coastal communities.

The main issue highlighted in media reports on the amendments is the proposal to divide the province into two zones with the same protections for the south—the Okanagan, Vancouver Island and Lower Mainland—and more lenience in zone two—the Kootenays and the north.

The presentation thus offered motive: removing valuable real estate in the Kootenays,

Several water stewardship council members suggested the logic behind the amendments is also scientifically flawed.

“Soils being better in the south, that isn’t necessarily the case,” said Denise Neilsen, a researcher at Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada. “The Peace River soils, for example, are potentially very productive soil. It’s really climate that is the limiting factor.”

Both Neilsen and her colleague, Scott Smith, said climate data indicates growing seasons are getting longer in the north, making the land far more valuable and indicating the premise of the two-zone system is backward.

The amendments also place subdivision decisions in the hands of local panels, Janmaat noted, saying there is already research to show this approach has not worked well with the six regional panels created in 2002.

Drawing on a study done by Ryan Green, out of the Environmental Law Clinic at the University of Victoria, he suggested local panels are far more susceptible to listening to the local advocates and approving subdivisions than a Agricultural Land Commission body.

“We love the Agricultural Land Commission,” said Coldstream councillor Maria Besso.

Local councils are happy to turn over decision making to a higher power and be one-step removed from the process, she said, as it’s the best way to protect the land reserve from the persuasive argument of a friend or neighbour of the council.

 

Kelowna Capital News

Just Posted

A search is underway for David Borden in Oyama, since he was last seen Wednesday, June 16. (Contributed)
UPDATE: Missing Lake Country man found

Family thanks Facebook community for sharing photo of missing man

Provincial Health Officer Dr. Bonnie Henry talks about B.C.’s plan to restart the province during a press conference at Legislature in Victoria, Tuesday, May 25, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chad Hipolito
Interior Health COVID-19 cases falling slower than the rest of B.C.

More than a third of provincial cases announced Thursday came from the Interior

Kelowna Fire Department. (Phil McLachlan - Capital News)
Abandonded campfire results in Kelowna bushfire

The fire was measured at 20 feet by 20 feet in size and has been deemed not suspicious in nature

The Greater Vernon Chamber of Commerce will host the Valley Wide Business Expo May 4 at Predator Ridge Resort. (photo submitted)
Golf raffle helps Okanagan families score homes

Habitat for Humanity Okanagan swinging into action this summer with a new raffle

Bear wanders Kelowna on June 15. (Michelle Wallace/Facebook)
Bear climbs fence, uses crosswalk in Kelowna

The bear was spotted on Baron Road Wednesday evening

Jeanette Megens
KCR: Volunteering is sharing your story

Kelowna Community Resources shares stories of its volunteers in a weekly column

John Furlong told the Vancouver Board of Trade on Feb. 20, 2020 that he thinks the city could and should bid for the 2030 Winter Games. (CP photo)
PODCAST: John Furlong lays out a ‘provincial’ plan to host the 2030 Winter Olympics

Podcast: Chat includes potential role for Vancouver Island communities

The pilot of this single-engine propeller plane was unhurt after crash-landing in a Como Road orchard Friday, June 18. Photo: Laurie Tritschler
Plane crash lands into Grand Forks orchard, pilot injured

RCMP have secured the crash site, pending investigation by Transport Canada

Cannabis bought in British Columbia (Ashley Wadhwani/Black Press Media)
Is it time to start thinking about greener ways to package cannabis?

Packaging suppliers are still figuring eco-friendly and affordable packaging options that fit the mandates of Cannabis Regulations

A tenant walks in front of her home on Boundary Road on Friday, June 18, 2021 after it was destroyed by fire the night before in Chilliwack. (Jenna Hauck/ Chilliwack Progress)
Family homeless after fire rips through Chilliwack house

Turtle rescued, no one seriously hurt following Boundary Road fire in Chilliwack

BC Ferries’ newest Island Class vessel is experiencing an issue with one of its thrusters off the Algerian coast. Photo courtesy patbaywebcam.com.
BC Ferries newest vessel having mechanical issues in Mediterranean

Island 4 will be repaired in Spain before crossing Atlantic

Wild rabbits are all over Chilliwack, but people often think they’re someone’s lost pet and try to ‘save’ them. But the owner of Chilliwack’s Reptile Room says good intentions can have bad consequences for wild animals. (Photo by THE CANADIAN PRESS)
Owner of Chilliwack’s Reptile Room asks people to leave wild animals in the wild

Amber Quiring says people who think they’re helping are actually doing more harm than good

Fanny Chapman doesn’t just serve up Mexican flavours at the Kal Lake Food concession at Kal Beach, she also teaches Spanish. (Jennifer Smith - Morning Star)
Vernonites asked to share funniest Spanish translation stories

Mexicans living in town holding a contest to offer free Spanish classes

Most Read