Man sentenced for fatal Christmas Eve collision in the South Okanagan

Crown said they could not prove beyond a reasonable doubt that man was impaired

It was a Christmas Eve that Andrew David Cook and the family and friends of the woman killed in the car accident he caused, will probably never forget.

Driving north on Highway 97, it was near Kickininee Provincial Park around 8:30 a.m. on Dec. 25, 2015, he made the decision to move into the fast lane when he lost control of his Honda Odyssey, crossed the double yellow line and ran into a Chevrolet Spark in the southbound lane.

Cook, 22 at the time of the incident, who had alcohol in his blood content, was rushed to hospital. Arlene Shepherd, the 74-year-old woman driving the vehicle he hit, suffered broken ribs, a chipped pelvis and abdominal bleeding — her condition was considered serious but not life-threatening at the time. However, her medical condition deteriorated significantly with kidney failure and, after a month in hospital, she contracted pneumonia and died on Jan. 25, 2016.

“I just want to reiterate how much regret I have for that decision I made and my sincerest apologies to the family for the choices I made that morning,” said Cook, whose voice trembled as he spoke to Justice Allison Beames on Tuesday in Supreme Court during his sentencing. “I’m so, so sorry.”

In a joint submission, Cook plead guilty to driving without due care. The impaired driving causing death, driving while over the legal limit and dangerous driving causing death charges were stayed. He was sentenced to 90 days in prison, to be served at the Okanagan Correctional Centre, and a two year driving prohibition. The maximum sentence this charge holds is six months in jail and a $2,000 fine.

Related: ICBC bad driver crackdown popular with public, survey finds

Defence lawyer Don Skogstad said the driving conditions were unfavourable that morning and other drivers were seen using the fast lane to pass slower vehicles. Skogstad said Cook also made the decision to pass, however he lost control in the lane that was allegedly not plowed, crossed the unbarricaded centre lane and struck the other vehicle.

“It’s a miscalculation, as well as a young fellow not familiar with the elimination rates of alcohol,” said Skogstad.

Crown counsel Kurt Froehlich conceded that many of the details of the investigation, as shown in the preliminary inquiry held in 2017, left them with the belief that it could not be proven, beyond a reasonable doubt, the original charges of impairment and the blood alcohol content. Froehlich said Cook had puked twice in the ambulance and the smell of alcohol prompted the impaired driving investigation.

Related: B.C. cities among cities with highest number of impaired drivers

It was stated by Justice Beams there could have been challenges to the investigation as a result of having transport Cook to the hospital to deal with injuries from the accident and ensuring he had access to proper counsel. She added if the trial went ahead he could have been found not guilty of all three of the charges.

Justice Beames read victim impact statements from Shepherd’s family and letters written in support of Cook before agreeing to the joint submission. She said the death of Sheppard must have been “horrific” news to her friends and family — to which Beames said she assumed she had many based on the words written in the statements.

“She was at least conscious for some period of time before her admission into hospital, it is not clear to me how long, but based on the very impactful victim impact statements that I read, it is clear that her first concern was the condition of Mr. Cook which speaks volumes with respect to her character,” said Beames.

Beames said Cook has shown remorse through his words and demeanour in court.

“I have no doubt an accident like this which causes the premature and tragic death of another is a life-changing event and Mr. Cook is conducting himself as if that is the case,” said Beames.

To report a typo, email: editor@pentictonwesternnews.com.

Kristi Patton | Editor

KristiPatton

Send Kristi Patton an email.
Like the Western News on Facebook.
Follow us on Twitter.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Okanagan youth drink, smoke and have sex more than anywhere else in B.C.

The survey was conducted by the McCreary Centre Society in 2018

Okanagan spring concert guide

A look at the top acts performing in the Okanagan from Feb. 18. to June. 21.

Kelowna’s Dr. Knox grabs No. 1 seed at junior provincials

The Falcons girls team heads to the championships in Langley this weekend

UBC Okanagan to host Festival of Ideas with BC’s lieutenant governor

The inaugural event will feature a panel discussion with Janet Austin, B.C.’s lieutenant governor

Blair says RCMP have met Wet’suwet’en conditions, so barricades should come down

The Wet’suwet’en’s hereditary chiefs oppose the Coastal GasLink project

Sentenced for stealing pricey ring from Salmon Arm pawn shop

Accused vows to change criminal history through beating addictions

Morning Start: Want your plants to grow faster? Play them music

Your morning start for Thursday, February 20, 2020

Cyclist hit by semi truck in Vernon

Cyclist sustained non-life threatening injuries; police investigating

Federal minister pledges to meet Wet’suwet’en chiefs in B.C. over natural gas pipeline

The Wet’suwet’en hereditary chiefs say they are visiting Mohawk territory

2010 leader John Furlong urges Vancouver to bid for 2030 Winter Games

VANOC said the 2010 games broke even financially

Pipeline dispute: Tories put no-confidence motion on House of Commons agenda

Conservatives say they have no confidence in the Trudeau government to end the rail blockades

Canadians aboard coronavirus-ridden cruise ship to return home tonight

Among the infected are 47 Canadians who will have to remain in Japan for treatment

Most Read