Mantler trial: Police training under fire

Sgt. Jeremy Lane says Kelowna Mounties don't appear to be well-trained in how to perform high risk traffic stops

The training and experience level of the Kelowna RCMP officers involved in the Buddy Tavares arrest were under scrutiny as Const. Geoff Mantler’s assault causing bodily harm trial continued Friday.

Mantler’s charge stems from a kick he delivered to Tavares’ head while arresting the man in relation to a shots fired complaint. Tavares has testified that he had been shooting to scare off geese at the Harvest Golf Club on Jan. 7, 2011 when RCMP were alerted to the gunshots.

Sgt. Jeremy Lane, an expert in the area of police use of force, told the court that experience may play a part in an officer’s perception of threat cues present in a situation.

Your concern was that the junior officers had no experience to perceive threat cues, suggested defence lawyer Neville McDougall.

“That’s possible,” said Lane.

All five officers who eventually converged on the scene of the arrest had less than four years of experience and the court has heard no supervisor took charge of the situation prior to the completion of the arrest.

All of the officers had six months of on the job training after graduating from Depot in Regina; one officer’s trainer had only one year of experience, the court heard.

[That’s] basically a recruit training a recruit?” asked McDougall.

“Yes,” said Lane.

“And that concerns you?”

“A great deal,” Lane replied.

Earlier, Lane was asked if he believed the officers appeared to be well trained.

“Not in respect to code five vehicle stops,” he said. Code five is the term used by police to refer to high risk traffic stops. “Generally, police officer’s in Canada are well trained…. Every organization has their weaknesses.”

Lane earlier testified that Mantler didn’t follow his training in performing the vehicle stop, and that he put himself in harm’s way by approaching Tavares’ truck.

“A reasonable, well-trained officer would have remained behind cover,”  Lane added later.

Lane found that Mantler’s kick to Tavares, which was caught on video, was “not appropriate, justified or reasonable” and that Mantler put himself in a vulnerable situation that could have created an “exaggerated perception of threat.”

He based his finding on available information, which did not include a statement from Mantler.

He said his opinion “may not be” the same if he had heard from Mantler and agreed during defence questioning that if Mantler believed he was at risk of death or grievous bodily harm, the kick “could be justified.”

“Was a threat of death or grievous bodily harm imminent to Const. Mantler?” Crown counsel William Burrows later asked.

“I don’t see that,” said Lane.

Mantler’s decision to draw his gun in the situation, however, was deemed appropriate by Lane.

The trial continues next week.

 

 

Just Posted

Two-vehicle crash slows traffic on highway in Kelowna

A collision between two cars on Sunday morning at the corner of Highway 97 and Highway 33

Hodge: Welcome back Ben but about your leader

Charlie Hodge’s weekly column look at the Kelowna West byelection

Kelowna Lantern Festival kicks off Chinese New Year

The eighth annual Lantern Festival was held Saturday night

Popular stories from the week

Every Saturday, the Capital News highlights popular stories from the week

Mining led to mass production, says UBCO prof

Without destructive mining, mass production and consumption would not be possible

What’s happening

Check out what is happening this weekend in the Okanagan-Shuswap.

How to keep local news visible in your Facebook feed

Facebook has changed the news feed to emphasize personal connections. You might see less news.

Vees lose to Rivermen

First period proves costly in 5-3 loss to Rivermen.

B.C. VIEWS: Subsidy supercluster settles in B.C.

Ottawa, Victoria add to their overlapping ‘innovation’ budgets

Warriors rally for win over Grizzlies

West Kelowna scored five times in the third period Saturday at LePage Place to beat Victoria

OLYMPIC ROUNDUP: Canada’s first ever men’s ski slopestyle medal

Men’s hockey team beats South Korea and women’s curling reverses losing streak

Canada’s Beaulieu-Marchand wins bronze in Olympic slopestyle

The skier from Quebec City scored 92.40 on his second run

Russian athlete suspected of doping at PyeongChang Olympics

The case could be an obstacle to Russia’s efforts to have the Russian team formally reinstated

Most Read