Muzzling of scientists should bring public outcry

Scientists are very concerned about the muzzling of government researchers and manipulation of what data is released to the public.

Jeffrey Hutchings

The muzzling of scientists in the employ of the federal government is of serious concern to the scientific community and even scholarly societies such as the Canadian Society for Ecology and Evolution, which is meeting in Kelowna this week.

President Jeffrey Hutchings, Killam professor in science at Dalhousie University in Halifax, says they have written letters expressing their concerns to the prime minister about the cuts to government’s research capacity and also about the remaining scientists’ orders not to speak to the public without pre-approval.

“It’s a disconcerting example of control,” he adds.

In fact, it began when this government took office and got rid of the national science advisor position. “That was symbolic and indicated that science is not deemed relevant to decision-making and policy development,” he comments.

Personally, he said he believes that society is well-served by having unfettered access to high quality scientific advice from government scientists, as the basis for making decisions.

As it is now, release of scientific data is being manipulated by government, so that only that which presents the view the politicians prefer, is released to the public.

“There have been instances before this, but the extent of the current muzzling of scientists is greater than it’s ever been before,” he warns, adding, “Other countries look at us aghast, because we were viewed as a progressive, enlightened democracy.”

He points to countries such as the United Kingdom and the United States, as well as Australia and New Zealand, who all depend on science advisors, if not a panel of them to provide the science on which to base decisions.

And, it’s important that advice is transparent so that society knows what information decisions are based on. “Discussion is healthy,” he adds.

Science can also provide savings—it’s not always a cost, he says.

The community does appear to value science, he notes, and he believes it’s up to the community now to make its views known if it is concerned about receiving only ‘filtered science.”

Delegates discussed the issue at a session Monday afternoon at the UBCO campus where the conference is being held, called Science and Credible Biodiversity Policy.

 

jsteeves@kelownacapnews.com

 

 

Just Posted

Budget 2018: Kelowna to look at monitoring downtown security cameras 24 hours per day

Potential $30,000 budget item will be discussed further over objections of the mayor

Stalled work on Kelowna’s Rutland Centennial Park to get another look

During budget deliberations, mayor calls for further improvements to park to be discussed by council

UPDATE: Kelowna quarry fire deemed suspicious

A vehicle in a Stewart Road quarry burned Thursday morning.

Kelowna city council spends big on Glenmore fire hall

2018 budget: Upgrade of Glemore fire hall to include 12 full-time firefighters

Accident in Lake Country

Thursday morning commute slow on Highway 97 following MVI

VIDEO: Average Canadian food bill to rise by $348 in 2018

Atlantic Canada and B.C. will see the most increases for consumers

Border officers rally at B.C.’s Peace Arch

CBSA employees tire of ‘lack of respect’

FCC votes along party lines to end ‘net neutrality’

Move rolls back restrictions that keep big providers from blocking services they don’t like

Performance embodies true meaning of Christmas

Caravan Farm Theatre presents O. Henry’s The Gift of the Magi by Maristella Roca until Dec. 31

Family of Vancouver Island RCMP officer killed by drunk driver sues

Lawsuit seeks financial compensation from Kenneth Jacob Fenton

SPCA seizes 74 animals from Barriere property

Constables removed sheep, piglets, chickens and more

Penticton addiction recovery centre plan halted by neighbours

Recovery centre operator said neighbours bought property ‘in haste’

Reservations to be needed year-round at Garibaldi Park

Change will go into effect Jan. 2 to protest environment from overuse

Hergott: Is bystander inaction a crime?

Lawyer Paul Hergott discusses a recent racist tirade and the lack of action by those watching

Most Read