Supreme Court judge rules dangerous Peachland dog should be put down

Jake, a seven-year-old perro de presa canario, and another dog, attacked a leashed lhasa apso cross Jan. 1, 2015 while running of leash.

A death sentence handed to a Peachland dog by a B.C. provincial court judge has been upheld by the B.C. Supreme Court.

The appeal of the lower court’s ruling, handed down last year, was made by the dog’s owner Drew Panton, in a last-ditch effort to prevent the court-ordered euthanization of his seven-year-old perro de presa canario dog, named Jake.

In his written judgment, judge Ronald Skolrood of the B.C. Supreme Court upheld the earlier decision by the late provincial court judge Anne Wallace, who ruled Jake was a dangerous dog as defined by section 49 (10) of the B.C. Community Charter after Jake and a pitbull owned by Panton attacked a leashed, 12-year-old lhasa apso-Wheaton terrier cross named Charley on New Years Day 2015. As a result of the attack, Charley had to be put down.

In her earlier ruling, Wallace also found Jake to be a danger to other dogs and said she felt he could seriously injure or kill them if let loose. She said she felt there was no way of managing or eliminating that risk, so she ordered Jake be put down.

In the New Year’s Day attack, Jake was accompanied by a pitbull named Buddy. Both dogs were off leash at the time and Panton was not present.

In the ensuing court case, the regional district asked that both the attacking dogs be put down. But Wallace ruled while Buddy was also a dangerous dog, his life should be spared and he should be returned to Panton under strict control conditions.

In his ruling, Skolrood upheld Wallace’s order of strict conditions for Buddy’s care to ensure public safety. They included locking doors when Buddy was inside Panton’s house so the dog could not inadvertently get out, being kept in a secured area with signs when in the yard and when out in public, being leased and muzzled at all times.

The Supreme Court judge dismissed the regional district’s argument that Wallae erred in not  ruling Buddy should be kept, when in the yard, in the type of enclosure required by the regional district’s Responsible Dog Ownership Bylaw.

Skolrood’s judgment also allows the regional district to seek to recover impound costs from Panton for providing care and shelter for Jake from the date of Wallace’s original order on Sept. 3 to the date of the appeal.

 

Just Posted

Breaking: Okanagan Mountain Park fire forces evacuation alert

Properties from 6006 to 8888 Lakeshore Road are being placed on an evacuation alert

Carrot Mountain fire fans smoke over West Kelowna

A cluster of three fires are burning above West Kelowna

Complete list of B.C. Interior wildfire coverage

Up-to-date information on blazes happening the Kamloops Wildfire Centre

UPDATED: Prepare for Highway 97 to close again due to wildfire

Motorists may use an alternate route via Highway 97C, Highway 5A and Highway 3

Two fires caused by lightning at Big White last night

The fires are currently being contained

Breaking: Evacuation order, local state of emergency, for Mount Eneas wildfire

The BC Wildfire Service is battling a large wildfire alongside Highway 97 in Peachland.

Update: Summerland wildfire forces PIB state of emergency

More than 40 firefighters are on scene of the wildfire near Mount Conkle, just outside of Summerland.

Hockey trip fraudster receives house arrest

Man duped 16 families with Okanagan Elite Hockey Association out of over $100,000

Four wild fires still burning near Keremeos

One fire was extinguished and another reported after lightning came through area

‘Amazing Race Canada’ competitors face B.C. challenge

They drove Corvettes, mastered falconry basics, and ate blueberry pie in the Cowichan Valley

Installers to battle Team B.C.

Exhibition men’s fastball Saturday in Vernon

Grizzly bear jumps in river, chases B.C. kayaker

The bear got a bit too close for comfort along the Elaho River near Squamish

Parks Canada looks to shine light on cloudy future for historic sites

A plan is in place to produce 10-year plans designed to turn around sagging attendance figures

B.C. poet shines a bright light on struggle with homelessness

Book launch for John La Greca’s Homeless Memorial is at Vernon’s Gallery Vertigo July 21.

Most Read