Hergott: Concern over waivers

Lawyer Paul Hergott addresses the public saftey concern over waivers.

Another injured victim goes uncompensated because of a waiver, despite clear negligence.

This time, an adult snowboarder at Big White. Boarding from one of the easiest runs, Highway 33, down a known path to a parking lot.

Access down the path was permitted by a wide gap in a rope line that is erected and maintained by Big White along ski runs to warn of hazards.

Big White was also responsible for snow removal in the parking lot at the bottom of the path. One morning, while Gary Fillingham and his family were enjoying the mountain, the removal of snow along the bottom part of that path created a sudden, 10 foot drop-off.

The contractor doing that snow removal failed to close the gap in the rope line to warn of the hazard that had been created.

Mr. Fillingham suffered serious injuries when he encountered that sudden drop-off and fell to the parking lot below.

Madam Justice Adair, in her September 26, 2017, decision of Fillingham v. Big White Ski Resort Limited, 2017 BCSC 1702, found that the snow removal contractor had been negligent.

But she dismissed Mr. Fillingham’s lawsuit because of the waiver.

This is a timely reminder of the unfairness of waivers as we gear up for another ski season in the Okanagan.

It is fair and reasonable that a ski resort be protected from frivolous lawsuits. Skiing and boarding are higher risk activities. We shouldn’t be able to sue for injuries arising from commonly known and understood risks of the activities we choose to participate in.

But it’s a completely different story when the ski resort, itself, causes a dangerous hazard.

Should we be upset with Madam Justice Adair for upholding the waiver in this case? No. She was applying the law.

A change of the law was recommended 23 years ago in an October, 1994 report of the Law Reform Commission of British Columbia. Here is a link to the Executive Summary and Recommendations.

The executive summary notes a lack of public understanding of how powerful waivers are:

“The scope that comprehensive waivers can have is little understood by the public. A belief persists that waivers “are not worth the paper they’re written on” or that they “don’t hold up in court.” Even though this fallacy has been repeatedly contradicted in recent, fairly well-publicized cases in British Columbia, the Commission still received comments in this vein.”

This lack of public understanding continues today. I know that because of feedback to my previous columns on the topic of waivers.

The executive summary points to a serious public safety concern about waivers:

“The concern about public safety arises because comprehensive waivers protect operators not only against frivolous claims, but also from legal responsibility for their own negligence and that of their employees. With potential liability greatly reduced or eliminated, an operator may be slower to correct a dangerous situation or make needed safety improvements, particularly if it involves significant cost.”

Absence of legal accountability and consequences leads inevitably to a reduced level of care. It’s just common sense.

Not only are these powerful waivers unfair, but they are dangerous.

Why have the recommendations of the Law Reform Commission not been implemented?

Because we, the public, have not demanded it. Continuing, widespread ignorance about the powerful impact of waivers is getting in the way of what’s right.

Please stand up for a change in the law. Talk to your MLA. Encourage others to read this column and do the same.

Just Posted

Truck fire forces evacuation of Lake Country gas station

No one was injured as firefighters quickly contained blaze at the Shell on Sunday afternoon

Gas leak contained near Lakeshore Road

Ruptured line was quickly contained Sunday morning by Kelowna Fire Department

High winds cause havoc for sailors

Kelowna Fire Department assists boats with broken masts on Okanagan Lake

Late night confrontation between two men in Peachland

RCMP was called to the scene of a physcial encounter on Saturday evening where one man was injured

Search continues after human remains located

The search of the property in the 2200 block of Salmon River Road enters its fourth day

VIDEO: Sears liquidation sales continue across B.C.

Sales are expected to continue into the New Year

Rockets raise money for autism

Western Hockey League club hosts third annual Family Day Sunday in Kelowna

WATCH: 10,000 signatures gained to stop ‘no pets’ rental policy

Pets OK BC said about 1,700 animals were surrendered to the BC SPCA last year due to housing issues

A golden opportunity

Orthodontist offers sweet deal for the pocketbook

Who is Curtis Sagmoen?

The Observer reveals what we know about the man attached to the Silver Creek property where human remains were found

VIDEO: Oprah Winfrey and a celebrities attend ‘B.C. Miracle Concert’

Fundraiser featured Foster, Steven Tyler, The Tenors, Matteo Bocelli, Laura Bretan, Carly Rae Jepsen

First-place Warriors edge Caps, visit ‘Backs today

West Kelowna scores twice in 25 seconds early in third to overtake Cowichan Valley in BCHL action

Grab a book; thank your librarian

All libraries are cornerstones of their communities and we celebrate them during library month

Five decades of volunteering

Even though she is approaching 70, Merle kindred continues to volunteer around the world

Most Read