Hergott: Personal injury claims don’t include ‘bonus’ jackpot

Do whatever you can, within reason, to make your claim as small as possible.

Many of my columns contain advice that is not expected from the popular culture’s generated sleazy image of a personal injury lawyer.

Being honest and forthright, for example, is the direct opposite of what many would expect a personal injury lawyer to recommend.

I’m going to hit you with another one: Do whatever you can, within reason, to make your claim as small as possible.

I can hear the sarcastic commentary now: “Oh, OK. I’m going to go to that lawyer. I’m going to hire the lawyer who is going to help me figure out not how to maximize my claim, but rather to minimize it!”

A personal injury claim is, essentially, a legal right to compensation. What are you being compensated for? Your losses.

The bigger your losses, the bigger your claim.

Conversely, the smaller your losses, the smaller your claim. There is no “bonus.”

There is only recovery of loss. When you factor in the one-third fees you are going to pay your lawyer, you in fact end up significantly “in the red.”

Your best hope is to recover compensation for two-thirds of your losses.

The bigger your losses, the further you end up in the red, because more and more is taken by your lawyer in fees.

For a very small claim, with losses of only $9,000, you end up “in the red” about $3,000 ($9,000 minus lawyer fees).

For a larger claim, with losses of $90,000, you end up “in the red” about $30,000.

Who benefits from maximizing your losses?  Your lawyer. Who loses?  You.

That’s the dollars and cents argument for keeping your losses as small as possible.

It just so happens that there is also a legal duty to do so. It’s called a “duty to mitigate”

A very recent decision of the Supreme Court of British Columbia quotes the following authoritative statement of the law:

“Mitigation goes to limit recovery based on an unreasonable failure of the injured party to take reasonable steps to limit his or her loss. A plaintiff in a personal injury action has a positive duty to mitigate but if a defendant’s position is that a plaintiff could reasonably have avoided some part of the loss, the defendant bears the onus of proof on that issue…”

Turning that into English, you have an actual legal obligation to take reasonable steps to end up as little “in the red” as possible.

If you fail to do so, ICBC won’t have to reimburse you for the losses that you could have made smaller had you acted reasonably.

For example, if your injury disables you from returning to your very heavy work as a drywall installer, but you would be able to handle less physically heavy work such as working at a desk or working as a salesperson, you have a legal duty to try to get those other jobs.

If you sit back and do nothing, and ICBC is able to prove that you would have been successful finding alternate work and earning at least a portion of the income you would have earned as a drywaller, the court will not reimburse you for that portion.

You will end up with zero compensation for that portion of your losses.

People who are laid off and qualify for Employment Insurance are required to look for work.

The same thing goes for people claiming compensation for injury losses.

The difference is that the Employment Insurance system is not going to hire a lawyer to cross-examine you on how hard you tried to find another job.

This “duty to mitigate” is nothing to worry about. It’s not some “dark magic” that ICBC will be able to use to kill your claim.

It’s all about acting reasonably. If you are the least bit unsure, get advice early on about what steps you could be taking to mitigate your losses and eliminate the possibility that ICBC can successfully “blame the victim” on this point.

Just Posted

Kelowna DJs organize own shows to fill gap in music scene

The DJs wanted to create somewhere people could enjoy their music safely

Rediscover Rutland: There’s never a dull moment in the neighbourhood

Laurel D’Andrea, with URBA, is sharing a few upcoming events

Kelowna budget carryovers won’t add to taxation demand

Council’s carryover budget requests will advance work for the city

Warm temperatures here to stay in Kelowna

Spring has finally sprung in the Central Okanagan

Kelowna welcomes building permit applications for “earth homes”

Kelowna welcomes carriage and container “earth homes” when mandatory inspections are completed

Defiant vigil starts healing in New Zealand after massacre

Police say the gunman in the shooting that killed 50 acted alone

Horvat scores 16 seconds into OT as Canucks beat Blackhawks 3-2

Pettersson sets rookie scoring record for Vancouver

No injuries, pollution in Vancouver Harbour ship collision: Transport Canada

Transportation Safety Board says it has deployed a team of investigators look into the incident

Budget 2019: Five things to watch for in the Liberals’ final fiscal blueprint

Finance Minister Bill Morneau will release the Trudeau government’s final budget on Tuesday

New concussion guidelines launched for Canada’s Olympians, Paralympians

The guidelines will be in effect at this summer’s Pan American, Parapan American Games in Lima, Peru

In Photos: Classic snowmobiles pushed to their limits in fun races

The Burner in Malakwa served as the venue for races show cases older sleds

Alphonso Davies doubtful for Canada game against French Guiana in Vancouver

Canada will be without injured captain Scott Arfield and veteran Will Johnson

Okanagan organization helps provide water for all in Nepal

Presentation shares success of project at Okanagan Science Centre March 27

Most Read