Hergott: Placing trust in your legal counsel

…great care needs to be taken to choose (service providers) who are worthy of our trust.

In a judgment released  Nov. 17, 2015, an Ontario Superior Court Judge lambasted the way a prominent class action law firm gets paid.

The judgment provides an important lesson.

I have written in support of class action lawsuits and I maintain my support. The problem in this case wasn’t the class action itself, it was the prosecuting lawyers’ arrangement for getting paid.

The claim had to do with premature deterioration of the rubber grips on some Sony Playstation 4 video game controllers. When returned for repair or replacement, customers were improperly charged a shipping fee.

This kind of case is perfectly suited to a class action proceeding. It would make no sense at all for any, single, victim of the improper charge to bring a lawsuit against Sony seeking reimbursement.

Put all the victims together, though, and the combined claim might be large enough that a lawsuit makes sense and a huge company can be held accountable to help prevent future injustice.

Class action lawsuits can be incredibly lucrative for the lawyers who pursue them.

In this case, the prosecuting law firm, Merchant Law Group (MLG), had estimated that anywhere from several thousand to several hundred thousand people had been wrongfully charged.

At the agreed reimbursement amount of $20 per victim, legal fees on a contingency basis could be millions of dollars.

Ironically, because of the court’s chastisement of MLG’s legal fees arrangement, and perhaps comically, MLG’s estimate was off.

Only about 400 customers had sent their controllers back and been improperly charged by Sony. The resulting settlement was $8,000.

It was suggested by Sony’s lawyers “…that this could be the smallest Canadian class action settlement on record.” In short, it was not a lucrative endeavour for MLG.

Class action settlements, however small, have to be approved by the court, which brought this one before Mr. Justice Belobaba. The court was also required to determine MLG’s entitlement to legal fees, which is what led to MLG’s legal fee arrangement being examined and lambasted.

MLG’s arrangement with its clients was described by the court as follows: “Don’t worry about our legal fees, we’ll get the defendant to pay them as part of the settlement agreement.”

This arrangement had MLG negotiating two things with the defence— one was compensation for their clients; the other was their legal fees.

The glaring conflict of interest between lawyer and client was identified by Mr. Justice Belobaba as follows: “…legal counsel is not only motivated to negotiate a settlement in almost any amount, his or her very involvement in the negotiation with the defendant creates a glaring conflict of interest because every dollar that can be deducted from the class members’ settlement amount is a dollar that can potentially be added to class counsel’s legal fees amount.”

Mr. Justice Belobaba chastised the arrangement in the clearest of terms: “It must be obvious to anyone who gives this even a moment’s thought, that this type of settlement-driven legal fees arrangement in class action litigation is fundamentally and profoundly unacceptable.”

He expresses his shock as follows: “I must confess that I was somewhat shocked to hear this. An experienced class action firm was telling me in open court, and with a straight face, that ‘many’ of its class action legal fee arrangements were like the one that was before me…”

It might well be that the lawyers at MLG are ultra conscious about the glaring conflict of interest between themselves and their clients, and carefully negotiate their own legal fees in such a way that results in fair results to their clients.

As much as we try to avoid them, conflicts of interest between lawyers and clients are ever present, regardless of the fee arrangement.

Lawyers billing by the hour face the conflict of interest that the more hours they spend, the more money they make, each dollar coming out of their client’s pocket.

Lawyers billing on a contingency fee arrangement face the conflict of interest that quick settlements at inevitably low settlement amounts are more lucrative than spending the time and money to properly work up a case to achieve full and fair compensation.

This is not unique to lawyers. This applies to all hourly rate and percentage fee service providers, from automobile mechanics to real estate agents.

The bottom line is that we are all at the mercy of the service provider, to some extent, and great care needs to be taken to choose those who are worthy of our trust.

Kelowna Capital News

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

David Short ended up losing everything after a fall rendered him unable to work, or pay his bills. His saving grace? Cooking. (Phil McLachlan - Capital News)
Untold: How cooking helped a Kelowna man stay off the streets

David Short spent over a year on the street after suffering a seizure

This historic photo is of Kelowna City Park aquatic facilities in 1954. 

The recently renovated facilities were remodelled to create the new Ogopogo Stadium and Pool capable of seating 5,000 spectators. This facility hosted sporting activities as well as dances, banquets, weddings, meetings, concerts, and water musicals. 

The Ogopogo Stadium also hosted Canadian Championships in rowing, diving, swimming, hydroplane and speedboat races. 

The photo was originally posted to the group Old Kelowna on Facebook back in 2014.
A look back at Kelowna’s past

Ice race on Wood Lake circa 1992

Dr. Bonnie Henry, provincial health officer, updates British Columbians about COVID-19 at a press conference earlier this week. (B.C. Government image)
B.C.’s 1st case of COVID-19 confirmed a year ago today

Here’s a look at some of the key dates in the province’s fight against the novel coronavirus

Grade 6 class students at Watson Road Elementary had an opportunity to learn about woodworking by building their own toolboxes. (Contributed)
Toolbox project rewarding for Central Okanagan students

Initiative benefits high school and elementary school classes

Crown prosecutors have stayed attempted murder charges against Kelowna’s Jesse Pez. (Phil McLachlan - Capital News)
Man accused in Kelowna Halloween stabbing has attempted murder charge stayed

The Crown only proceeds with charges when evidence provides ‘a substantial likelihood of conviction’

British Columbia Health Minister Adrian Dix looks on as Provincial Health Officer Dr. Bonnie Henry addresses the media during a news conference at the BC Centre of Disease Control in Vancouver B.C. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jonathan Hayward)
B.C. announces 485 new COVID-19 cases, fewest deaths in months

‘The actions we take may seem small, but will have a big impact to stop the virus,” urges Dr. Henry

Grad student Marisa Harrington and her supervisor Lynneth Stuart-Hill say preliminary results from a study into the affects of stress on hospital nurses show an impact on sleep and heart variability. (Courtesy of Marisa Harrington)
University of Victoria study shows stress impact on B.C. nurses

Stress may be impacting sleep, heart health of hospital nurses in Victoria region

Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News
Search called off for small plane that went down in rough water south of Victoria

Plane bound for Port Angeles from Alaska believed to have one occupant, an Alaskan pilot

RCMP released this photo on Jan. 27, 2021 of Terrance Jones, 40, a Caucasian man with a closely shaved head, brown eyes, dirty blonde or brown hair, and a thin mustache and beard. The inside of his right arm is covered in tattoos, including one of a face. (Kamloops RCMP photo)
RCMP want public’s help to locate Shuswap man wanted on charge of attempted murder

Sicamous man was arrested previously on Jan. 11 for allegedly breaching conditions of release

Royal B.C. Museum conservator Megan Doxsey-Whitfield kneels next to a carved stone pillar believed to have significance as a First Nations cultural marker by local Indigenous people. The pillar was discovered on the beach at Dallas Road last summer. Museum curatorial staff have been working with Songhees and Esquimalt Nation representatives to gain a clearer picture of its use. (Photo courtesy Royal BC Museum)
Stone carving found on Victoria beach confirmed Indigenous ritual pillar

Discussion underway with the Esquimalt and Songhees about suitable final home for the artifact

Cannabis bought in British Columbia (Ashley Wadhwani/Black Press Media)
Is it time to start thinking about greener ways to package cannabis?

Packaging suppliers are still figuring eco-friendly and affordable packaging options that fit the mandates of Cannabis Regulations

Former Vancouver Giants forward Evander Kane is seen here in Game 7 of the second round of the 2009 WHL playoffs against the Spokane Chiefs (Sam Chan under Wikipedia Commons licence)
Gambling debts revealed in details of bankruptcy filing by hockey star Evander Kane

Sharks left winger and former Vancouver Giants player owes close to $30 million total

Othman “Adam” Hamdan, pictured in front of Christina Lake’s Welcome Centre, was acquitted of terrorism related charges in 2017. He has been living in Christina Lake since November 2020. Photo: Laurie Tritschler
Man acquitted on terrorism charges awaits deportation trial while living in Kootenays

Othman Ayed Hamdan said he wants to lead a normal life while he works on his upcoming book

Most Read