Hergott: Seniors get a break in personal injury claim lawsuits

Is it fair to compensate a senior less than 1/2 that for a 40-year-old because he will suffer chronic pain for less than 1/2 as long?

One key goal that we strive for in our legal system is consistency.

If two different judges are faced with similar facts, we expect that they will come to similar conclusions.

In the context of a personal injury claim, we expect that people suffering similar losses will receive similar financial compensation for those losses; one person suffering a certain degree of chronic pain should be compensated at a similar level as another person suffering a similar degree of chronic pain.

That sounds easy enough, but often what sounds easy in theory becomes very difficult in practice.

No two people’s life circumstances are ever identical, and therefore the impact of pain and other symptoms is never the identical.

Let’s say, for example, two people suffer very similar injuries and are left with very similar levels of chronic symptoms, one of the injured victims is 40 and the other is 70.

We’ll put them both in the same car, in the same crash

Both are pain free before the crash. Both develop lower back pain that becomes chronic.

Each will suffer that lower back pain for the rest of his or her life.

According to an Internet life expectancy calculator, the senior, if a man, has a life expectancy of another 17 years.

The 40-year-old will have a life expectancy of another 43 years.

Should the senior receive less compensation?

Is fair financial compensation for the senior less than one-half that for the 40-year-old because he will suffer chronic lower back pain for less than one-half as long?

On the face of it, the analysis seems to have some logical merit, but it smells to high heaven.

Our courts have struggled with exactly this scenario, multiple times.

Rather than arbitrarily discounting a senior’s entitlement to compensation, our courts have decided that a senior’s loss might even require greater compensation.

There is a passage from a 1967 court judgment that is often quoted by justices of our courts when considering how to compensate those of advancing years.

The judge’s view was expressed as follows: “I take the view myself that when one has a person in advancing years, in some respects an impairment of movement may perhaps be more serious than it is with a younger person.”

After acknowledging the argument of the defence, that compensation should be lower, the judge continued as follows: “…it is important to bear in mind that as one advances in life, one’s pleasures and activities particularly do become more limited, and any substantial impairment in the limited amounts of activity and movement which a person can undertake, in my view, becomes all the more serious on that account.”

Seniors do experience discrimination as a result of their advanced age in our world, but I am pleased to report that such discrimination does not extend to our courts of law.

Just Posted

Kelowna students awarded for their heritage research

The Okanagan Regional Heritage Fair was held April 24

Kelowna dragon welcomed to the den

Lane Merrifield is the new dragon on Dragons’ Den

Lake Country man facing assault charges

A woman was seriously injured after an alleged aggravated assault on April 22

State of emergency issued for Mill Creek

Risk of flooding increases as runoffs from higher elevations reach the valley bottom in Kelowna

Send us your spring pics for a chance to win

The Capital News is collecting photos of you taking advantage of this nice weather

VIDEO: B.C. ‘escapologist’ stuns judges on Britain’s Got Talent

Matt Johnson says televised water stunt was closest he’s come to death

WATCH: Moms Stop The Harm respond to opioid crisis

Someone asked her if she does the work for her son. McBain said: “No, actually. I do it for your son.”

Haley Blais tackles social norms through music tour

Haley Blais encourages people not to be discouraged by social norms and to be who they are

Been a long day? Here’s cute puppies in training

Group is training next batch of assistance dogs at Vancouver International Airport

B.C. skydiver lands safely after cutting away main chute

Greater Victoria emergency services called after witnesses saw spiralling chute

78 Mexican farmworkers displaced after fire tears through building on B.C. farm

Flames broke out Thursday morning in building that housed up to 80 workers at Abbotsford farm

3 year-old golden lab from Calgary missing after car accident east of Revelstoke

The car that Abbie — a three year old Golden lab was driving in — flipped over and ended up in a ditch early this morning

Inmates, machines adding muscle to Oliver flood fight

Inmates are packing 250 sandbags a day, but RDOS says newly acquired machine will push 6,000 an hour

Cartoonist captures public mood following Toronto, Humboldt tragedies

Cartoonist said he was trying to find a bit of positivity with an image that has garnered attention

Most Read