Hergott: Small claims court option to achieve justice

What if ICBC wrongly assesses you as being at fault for a crash?

If a police officer tickets you for a driving offence that you did not commit, there are instructions on the back side of the ticket for how you can dispute the ticket.

You will end up in front of a Justice of the Peace in ‘traffic court,’ and with the opportunity to defend yourself.

But what if ICBC wrongly assesses you as being at fault for a crash?

Consequences of an incorrect fault assessment can be severe. Depending on your driving history and your income, the assessment can push your insurance premiums up so high that you can no longer afford to drive.

The loss of your car can have a significant impact on your ability to find and maintain work, let alone the impact on your recreational pursuits.

The representatives of ICBC who make fault assessments are doing their best, I assume, with the information available to them.

Often, though, they are facing a “he said, she said” situation. If the other driver is dishonest, how is ICBC to figure out which one of you is telling the truth?

The default is a 50/50 liability assessment. Like King Solomon’s threat of cutting the baby in half, both drivers lose because they both end up with insurance consequences.

You are the driver who really loses, though, because you were the innocent driver. What do you do? The ICBC website provides internal options—talking to an ICBC manager or asking for an internal process they call a  claims assessment review. But neither of those processes can resolve a situation where one driver says one thing and another driver says something else.

The ICBC website correctly notes: “Please note, the courts have the final say about who’s liable for a motor vehicle crash”, and lists “Dispute your claim in court” as an option if you disagree with ICBC’s fault assessment.

Getting your day in court is not as easy, but it’s not the unsurpassable mountain range you might feel it is.

If you want some inspiration, I invite you to read the Kelowna Small Claims decision of Tough v. ICBC, which can be found with an Internet search of Provincial Court of British Columbia judgments.

Eric Tough was the victim of a crash at age 17. He was turning left when an oncoming vehicle broadsided him.

He was not injured, miraculously, but his $750 “beater” of a car was destroyed and his insurance premiums priced him out of being able to afford to drive because ICBC assessed him 100 per cent at fault.

Young Mr. Tough was the classic “David” in a “David and Goliath” situation With the help of his step-father, he picked up a stone and put it into his slingshot by commencing a small claims lawsuit against the offending driver as well as ICBC. They did not hire a lawyer.

After reviewing the evidence, Provincial Court Judge Wallace issued a decision reversing the fault assessment that had been made by ICBC, completely exonerated young Mr. Tough.

Small claims court is a wonderfully accessible way to achieve justice without having to incur the exorbitant expense of hiring a lawyer.


Just Posted

Cherry season has arrived in the Okanagan

Dust off those cherry pie recipes

Sun-Rype Products Ltd. and Mamas for Mamas announce partnership

The partnership will help support mothers in crisis

Two artists put on divine feminine art show in Kelowna

The show will be on for the month of July

Poke bowl craze is coming to Kelowna

Pacific Poke opens Downtown this July

First annual BE Awards celebrate Thompson Okanagan Businesses

Kelowna businesses shine in several categories

Homeless people living on ‘Surrey Strip’ move into modular housing

BC Housing says 160 homeless people are being moved into temporary Whalley suites from June 19 to 21

Port of Prince Rupert names Shaun Stevenson as new CEO

Stevenson has worked for the port for 21 years as vice president of trade development

Senate officially passes Canada’s marijuana legalization bill

Bill C-45 now moves to royal assent, which is the final step in the legislative process

Fake attempted abduction not funny to B.C. neighbourhood residents

Two teenage boys won’t face criminal charges after scaring girl

New craft brewery location chosen in Kelowna

Rustic Reel Brewing says it will produce beer at new location on Vaughan Avenue

Mosquitoes out in full force already? Blame the weather

But a B.C. mosquito expert says the heat wave will help keep the pests at bay

Man pleads not guilty in 1987 slayings of B.C. couple

William Talbott of SeaTac was arraigned Tuesday in Snohomish County Superior Court

New GOP plan: Hold kids longer at border – but with parents

Move would ease rules that limit how much time minors can be held with their parents

Without a big data strategy, Canadians at risk of being ‘data cows’

Presentation said artificial intelligence could give Facebook and Amazon even more power

Most Read