Hergott: Take steps to get better after an accident

Is it fair that a victim’s efforts to get better be scrutinized? I think it’s a sensible law, but it can lead to injustice.

Paul Hergott

Find out what you can do to get better, and do it.

It’s one of my key pieces of legal advice for those consulting with me after a crash.

Legal advice? Isn’t that just common sense?

It actually takes me a bit of time to fully explain that advice.

It might not be good enough for you to focus solely on your recovery.

Every step you take, or don’t take, is going to be scrutinized at some point.

Why? There is a law that actually requires you to take all reasonable steps to getbetter.

It is a law that leads to the distasteful notion of blaming the victim.

Someone has shown such disregard for the safety of others that they somehow failed to notice traffic ahead of them stopping, and they crash into the back of a stopped vehicle.

Is it fair that their victim’s efforts to get better be scrutinized?

I think it’s a sensible law, but it can lead to injustice.

The victim’s entitlement to fair, financial compensation for their injuries and losses can be reduced if an ICBC defence lawyer, with 20/20 hindsight, can show that the victim did not take all reasonable steps to get better.

Sure, you did this, this, this and this, but you didn’t do enough.

A recent case of our British Columbia Supreme Court, Harmati v. Williams, 2016BCSC 2199, has clarified a critical aspect of the law, which reduces the possibility of injustice.

There must be evidence that had you done more, or done things differently, it would have made a difference in your recovery.

Madam Justice Choi, at paragraph 126 of her decision, concludes the following with regard to the defence attempt to show that the plaintiff failed to take all reasonable steps to get better (failed to mitigate her losses): “Because of this lack of evidence about the nature of the losses which could have been mitigated, and the potential success of such mitigation efforts, I do not find that the Defendants have proven that the Plaintiff has failed her duty to mitigate….”

While the 20/20 hindsight view of this lady’s attempts to get better showed that she had fallen short, she still recovered 100 per cent compensation for her losses, without reduction, because it wasn’t established that she would have had a better outcome had she done things differently.

It’s better not to get to that point, though.

My preference is to help injured victims navigate through their care, knowing that their care decisions will be scrutinized.

It is best to avoid the “failure to mitigate” argument from coming up in the first place.

Just Posted

Accident at busy Kelowna intersection

There are reports of a two vehicle accident on Highway 97 leading through Kelowna

Inquiry underway in Kelowna murder case

A preliminary inquiry is taking place for the man accused in the 2014 death of Christopher Ausman

Dine Around Thompson Okanagan set to kick off

Popular event kicks off in Kelowna with a sold out launch party

Kelowna’s Capri-Landmark plan could carry big price-tag

City council told the ‘preferred’ concept plan could cost as much as $100 million over next 22 years

Okanagan nurse assists Rohingya refugees

Crystal Grymaloski volunteers with Samaritan’s Purse disaster response mission in Bangladesh

Kelowna artist creates fundraiser for a friend

Artist Laurie Koss was inspired by her friend’s cancer battle to help her keep fighting

Vying for pro deal, Twarynski steps up game

Flyers 2016 draft pick has scored 17 goals in the Kelowna Rockets’ last 21 games

Penticton bookkeeper nets 90 days for $60k embezzlement

Judith Kendrick pleaded guilty to fraud late last year, and was up for sentencing Tuesday morning

Kamloops Mounties investigate reported home invasion in Dallas home

Kamloops Mounties were called to the home just after midnight after reports of people yelling and kicking in a door

Poetry collection preserves Indigenous knowledge

B.C. author collaborates with Shuswap students, First Nations elders

Sunwing vacation passengers left at Abbotsford airport

YXX staffers receive praise for help to passengers; airline criticized

Salmon Arm council approves rainbow crosswalk

Location near Blackburn Park chosen

Ice dancers Virtue and Moir to carry flag for Canada at 2018 Olympics

The pair earned a gold medal at the 2010 Vancouver Olympic Games

Most Read