In Peachland, democracy in action was luck of the draw in 2018

Peachland picked its mayor by having her name drawn out of a box

There were plenty of stories that grabbed the headlines in the Central Okanagan in 2018, but likely the weirdest was the election—or rather selection—of Peachland’s mayor.

After voters voted and counters counted, and then re-counted, and then counted a third time, the result came down to luck of the draw—literally.

After the initial count, a recount and a judicial recount of the just over 1,600 votes cast for all five candidates who were vying for the mayor’s job, incumbent Cindy Fortin and one challenger, Harry Gough, remained tied at 804 votes apiece.

So, as per the district’s rules of what to do in such a situation, a B.C. judge, popped two identical pieces of paper with Fortin’s name and Gough’s name on them into a small green wooden box, gave it a shake and plucked out the winner’s name. Democracy in action.

Days earlier, on election night, it appeared Gough had defeated Fortin by just one-vote. But, with the closest of results possible, a recount was assured. That recount led to the discovery of an extra vote for Fortin, so the tie meant B.C. provincial court judge Ellen Burdett had to oversee another recount.

To do so, Burdett and three B.C. sheriffs jumped into a black SUV at the Kelowna courthouse, drove south to Peachland, and set up shop in the cozy confines of Peachland’s community hall.

There, in a surreal all-day session where only the judge, the sheriffs, the candidates and their respective representatives, along with pre-approved district staff to do the re-recount and pre-approved reporters were allowed to attend, the laborious process recounting every vote under Burdett’s watchful eye took place.

And, in the end….nothing changed. The result was still a 804-804 tie between Fortin and Gough.

So Burdett turned to the little green box.

In that moment, for a few seconds, the serious business of electing the municipality’s mayor took on an almost game-show-like feel. And in the end, it was Fortin who got to come on down because the price was right.

One of the first thing’s she said she planned to do once she was sworn-in again was to have her council look at a better way of breaking ties in Peachland elections in future.

And it served as a bit of wake-up call for other municipalities to check how they would deal with such a situation, too.

Elections, after all, are held to do the will of the people. Drawing names out of a hat—or in this case a box—kind of nullifies that.

Important political decisions, even local ones in small municipalities, should not come down to chance.

Alistair Waters is the assistant editor of the Capital News.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

West Kelowna Fire and Rescue gear up for annual ‘Fire in the Mountains’ initiative

WKPF is offering one individual the opportunity to spend up to 3 days with their firefighter hero’s hiking or paddling in one of BC’s pristine wilderness environments

Kelowna’s Sutherland Salvation Army thrift store closes permanently

The location has been facing challenges amid COVID-19

QUIZ: Do you know the truth?

In what has been described as a post-truth era, how much do you know about truth and lies?

Drowning incidents increase in Okanagan as summer picks up

There are now 23 drownings in the province to date, with four from the Okanagan

53 new COVID-19 cases, no new deaths cap off week of high infection rates in B.C.

Roughly 1,500 people are self-isolating because they either have COVID-19 or have been exposed to it

Local state of emergency declared near Okanagan home

Slope failure cited as City of Penticton issues notice at home in 600 block of Heather Road

Simon Cowell breaks his back falling from electric bike

Incident happened at his home in California

Therapeutic art for sale at Okanagan show

17th annual Awakening the Spirit Art Show and Sale presented by Vernon Canadian Mental Health Assoc.

VIDEO: Internet famous Yukon-based bhangra dancer explores Vancouver Island

Gurdeep Pandher spreads joy through dance, forms cross-cultural connections amid pandemic

Tech mogul growing North Okanagan’s wine industry

The founder of online dating site Plenty of Fish is developing 900 acres in Vernon

Fentanyl-laced powder being sold as cocaine in Kamloops

Interior Health has released a warning about very strong fentanyl in Kamloops

Unofficial holidays: the weird and wonderful things people celebrate around the world

On any given day of the year, there are several strange, silly or serious holidays to observe

North Okanagan ranch needs support to stay afloat

Founded in 1867, a fundraiser has been launched for the Historic O’Keefe Ranch

Most Read