Involuntary hospital admission

One of the areas in mental health treatment fraught with the most uncertainty and emotion is the area of involuntary hospital admission.

One of the areas in mental health treatment fraught with the most uncertainty and emotion is the area of involuntary hospital admission.

In most areas of medicine, an adult can choose whether and when to be treated.

This is true when it comes to mental illness as well, but there are instances when a person’s right to refuse treatment is over-ruled for their own safety or the safety of others.

For obvious reasons, this subject is governed by some specific criteria in law and we cannot simply admit our loved ones to hospital if they are not behaving the way we would like.

B.C.’s Mental Health Act covers involuntary hospital admission and sets out some guidelines for when a person can be involuntarily admitted and treated against his or her will.

Four basic criteria must be met in order for an involuntary admission to be warranted.

First, the patient must be suffering from a mental disorder impairing his or her ability to react to the environment or associate with others.

Second, the patient must be in need of psychiatric treatment in a hospital.

Third, the patient must require care in order to prevent substantial mental or physical deterioration or for the protection of self or others.

And fourth, the patient must be unwilling to become a voluntary patient.

Most of these criteria are fairly straightforward, but it is the third one that presents the most uncertainty for physicians and family members.

Although the criteria is quite broad and cites not only danger to self or others but also risk of physical or mental deterioration, it is usually interpreted quite narrowly.

Most physicians focus almost entirely on whether an individual is a physical danger to self or others. If that imminent danger is not present, they will not admit. In fact, the law leaves more room for interpretation.

By ignoring the clause dealing with substantial deterioration, many people are left to fend for themselves and see their conditions get a lot worse before they get the help they need.

This was arguably a contributing factor in last year’s tragic case of suicide.

A 22-year-old man with paranoid delusions slipped away from emergency caregivers and killed himself in a hospital staff washroom after his parents had spent years trying to have his worsening symptoms treated.

Although he was finally admitted against his will, his parents believed his condition had deteriorated significantly by that time and he may have benefited from adequate treatment trials much earlier.

As a result of this sad situation, a coroner’s inquest made 43 recommendations surrounding the interpretation of the Mental Health Act and the necessity of it being used in a timely and effective manner.

Civil liberty and choice are important and must be respected.

At the same time, there are times when we are very vulnerable and unable to think clearly for ourselves and in those times we may need to be protected from our illness for our own sake.

Our courts have interpreted this protection to include protection of harm to the person’s social, family, work or financial life. As you can imagine, this is much broader than simply protecting someone from doing physical harm to self or others.

It is important for physicians to understand the scope and details of the law surrounding involuntary hospital admission so they can make the most informed decisions when dealing with these situations.

Some health regions have stated plans to provide operational definitions of some of the clauses within this mental health law. This would be worthwhile in all jurisdictions to ensure we are protecting those who truly need it.

If you are interested in learning more about the Mental Health Act, check out the excellent guide online at:

Paul Latimer is a psychiatrist and president of Okanagan Clinical Trials.


Just Posted

The City of Kelowna needs your help to design its cultural plan

Residents are invited to take part in an online survey until Aug. 31

Councillors don’t like it but send tower proposal to public hearing anyway

Despite speaking out against Cedar Avenue project councillors say minds are still open

Ballet Kelowna to perform in China

For the first time Ballet Kelowna has been invited to perform in Beijing

B.C. Wine Info Centre feeling the impact of striking casino workers

The casino isn’t the only Penticton business feeling the brunt of the strike action

Kelowna cannabis company licensed to perform tests on the plant

GTEC Holding’s Zen Labs got its Health Canada licence in July

VIDEO: Visual recap of Vancouver Island MusicFest

Walk Off The Earth, Passenger, Arlo Guthrie among highlights

Okanagan mixed martial arts athlete ready for battle

Xcessive Force Fighting Championship comes to the Penticton Trade and Convention Centre

Temperature records break across southern B.C. as heat continues

Whistler broke a 70-year-old record high of 32.2 C with a temperature of 32.9 C

A’s sweep Pirates, host Twins to cap regular season

With just four games remaining in the regular season, the Okanagan Athletics’… Continue reading

Small house fire extinguished by Okanagan homeowner

Homeowner knocked down flames with hose before crews were on scene Tuesday morning

Come dance between the lakes

Powwow Between the Lakes returns to Penticton Indian Band in August

Hawaii volcano boat tours continue after ‘lava bomb’ injuries

“An explosion occurred near the shoreline hurling hot lava rocks towards the boat and injuring several passengers.”

Trump returns from summit with Putin to forceful criticism

“Shameful,” ”disgraceful,” ”weak,” were a few of the comments. Makes the U.S. “look like a pushover,” said GOP Sen. Bob Corker of Tennessee.

Obama to deliver Mandela address in likely rebuke to Trump

Former U.S. President Barack Obama Monday praised Kenya’s president and opposition leader for working together but said this East African country must do more to end corruption.

Most Read