Letter: C-51 strips us of our rights

This is a dangerous piece of legislation and is far more of a threat to our freedom than ISIS or al-Qaida ever was.

To the editor:

Every Canadian should be outraged at this latest attack on our human rights and democracy by Stephen Harper and his Conservative government. American legislation following the 9/11 terrorist attacks parallels Bill C-51 as it stripped the basic human rights of Americans. The effect on two Canadians was devastating.

The FBI arrested Canadian Maher Arar at JFK airport on Sept. 26, 2002 as he was traveling from Tunisia to Montreal, returning from a holiday. After Bush labeled him an ”enemy combatant,” he was denied legal counsel, prevented from seeking help from the Canadian embassy, and in a process called “rendition” he was flown to Syria, at that time an American client state. He was imprisoned and tortured for 13 months before it was determined that he had no connection to terrorism and was set free.

Omar Kadr, another Canadian, was arrested in Afghanistan at the age of 15 and imprisoned at Guantanamo in Cuba for eight years without ever being charged with a crime. He was tortured repeatedly, denied access to a lawyer, imprisoned with adults in a place where adult rape of children was rampant, and when he was finally given the right to appear before a military commission, in January of 2008, the UN Special Representative for Children in Armed Conflict was denied access to Kadr or to his farcical trial.

The UN attempted to have child soldiers like Kadr declared victims of war, rather than enemy combatants, but the American military ignored that attempt. At that military commission Kadr was given the choice of pleading guilty and spending another eight years behind bars or going back to Guantanamo and spending the rest of his life behind bars.

This is what we have to look forward to if Bill C-51 is adopted in Canada. This is a dangerous piece of legislation and is far more of a threat to our freedom than ISIS or al-Qaida ever was.

Patrick O’Neil,



Just Posted

Basement fire quickly extinguished

Fire crews quickly extinguished a basement fire at a home in Kelowna

New Central Okanagan school district office behind schedule

New building now expected to be completed by February 2018

West Kelowna neighbourhood fed up with criminal activity

Prowler frustrating West Kelowna residents

Kelowna motel robbed, suspect sought

The suspect threatened to harm the lone front desk clerk and demanded money.

Kelowna airport hosts accessibility event

Canucks Autism Network event brings families together to help deal with air travel

Heavy snowfall expected on Coquihalla

Snow forecast for mountain highways

Serious home invasion reported in Kamloops

Two people are in hospital with serious injuries following a home invasion

Annett finishes season on the podium at Ironman Arizona

Penticton triathlete sets new course record on the bike

Cash donations create purchasing power

Salvation Army and food banks stretch a donated dollar a long way

Hergott: A pedestrian’s legal obligation

Lawyer Paul Hergott questions the moral obligation of pedestrians and motorists

Huskies grab valley title in thriller over Bears

OKM defeats Boucherie in five-setter in Okanagan AAA final, both teams head to provincials

Coyotes grab Okanagan boys title

George Elliott defeats Seaton in AA volleyball final, seeded third heading to provincials

ICBC overbilling for crash repairs not the problem, dealers say

Collision repair shops reject union claim of inflated costs

Last day for shoeboxes at Kelowna Gospel Fellowship

Kelowna church has been gathering gifts for kids in need in countries around the world

Most Read