Letter: Court decision needed for change

You need a court decision to change the decision made in 2004 by the Provincial Approving Officer

To the editor:

In 2004 RDCO hired a consultant to review the possible extension of Menu and McCallum Roads (in West Kelowna) into the about-to-be-developed area beyond Victor Properties. The conclusion was that these neighbourhood roads could not safely handle the large increase of traffic that would result. RDCO concluded that only emergency access would be allowed through Menu and McCallum.

Subsequently, the Ministry of Transportation called for these roads to be opened and held a public meeting. Kurt Edmunds, Provincial Approving Officer, presided. He listened to various pros and cons and later that day gave his decision. He agreed with the original recommendation for an emergency access only for Menu Road and McCallum Road.

This was reiterated in a letter (June 1, 2004) from then Minister of Transportation, Hon. Kevin Falcon.

The Attorney-General, Hon. Geoff Plant, actually made it quite clear, that Kurt Edmunds is a Provincial Approval Officer and as such operates as an independent decision-making authority conferred by the legislature. The Attorney-General went on to state the only way to change this decision.

“Where an issue is raised concerning a decision or the decision-making process of a Provincial Approving Officer, the courts are charged with the power to review that decision or decision-making process.”

However, West Kelowna council and mayor have decided to have another go at this, notwithstanding the Attorney-General’s written statement that only a court can open the gates at Menu and McCallum Roads.

Councillors Neis, Dejong, Ophus and Winsby are of the opinion that the decision in 2004 was political. As the facts herein indicate, they are the ones making it political, assisting the developer to provide more access. Does opening theses roads make it easier to sell the lots/houses? It may allow them to have the houses closer together so they can sell more lots and make more money. Also it may allow them to build less costly houses, as they may not have to have sprinkler systems.

It is very clear that the decisions made in the past were for safety concerns and the current politicians are ignoring that and making it purely political.

Suffice it to say that you can change a name from RDCO to DWK to CWK but the law is still the law. You need a court decision to change the decision made in 2004 by the Provincial Approving Officer.

Steven Tuck, West Kelowna

Just Posted

Pavement Patty slows drivers near Rutland Elementary

New survey reveals unsafe school zones during 2018 back-to-school week

Kelowna church closes and makes room for Starbright

Starbright Children’s Development Centre meeting need for space with major real estate purchase

Black Mountain / sntsk‘il’ntən Regional Park starts to take shape

Student volunteers from three local schools work on trail building project

Kelowna’s Pleasure Painters to host day of art

The annual art sale will take place Oct. 20

Fire ignites at Kelowna homeless camp

No one was hurt in the incident, RCMP are investigating the cause of the fire

Your morning news in 90: Sept. 20, 2018

Tune in for 90 seconds to get the top headlines for the Okanagan, Shuswap and Similkameen.

The longest week: Carolinas worn out by Florence

Frustration and sheer exhaustion are building as thousands of people wait to go home seven days after the storm began battering the coast.

Vancouver councillors move ahead with policy for duplexes on detached home lots

Mayor Gregor Robertson says the decision is another step toward adding homes in the city for the so-called “missing middle.”

Canada’s goal is to play in a medal game at World Cup in Spain

The 2014 women’s world basketball championships were a coming out party for Canada.

World Anti-Doping Agency reinstates Russia

There was no mention of Russia publicly accepting a state-sponsored conspiracy to help its athletes win Olympic medals by doping.

Nanaimo’s Tilray pot stock continues rising, firm now worth more than $21 billion US

The B.C. company’s shares have risen more than 1,000 % since its initial public offering in July

Fresh-faced Flames fend off Canucks 4-1

Vancouver drops second straight NHL exhibition contest

VIDEO: B.C. deer struggles with life-preserver caught in antlers

Campbell River resident captures entangled deer on camera

Most Read