Letter: Housing First puts ‘horse behind the cart’

It is a wishful hope that free housing…will somehow motivate people off drugs and back on the straight and narrow path to recovery

To the editor:

After months of behind closed door planning, the scheme has finally hatched. In the name of compassion, [Kelowna city] council is asked to effectively displace low income senior citizens in order to accommodate untreated, homeless, mentally ill drug addicts.

Thankfully, timely alerts have been sounded by our local newspapers (It Starts With A Home, Barry Gerding, March 11 Kelowna Capital News).

This is more than a frivolous matter with major potential consequences for our community.

The Housing First movement urges us to put the cart before the horse. It is a wishful hope that free housing, without treatment commitment, will somehow motivate people off drugs and back on the straight and narrow path to recovery. So called experts claim it’s not fair to ask homeless people to prove their worth as citizens before moving them into housing. They all speak of benefits yet no one speaks of consequences.

What is not fair is the displacement involved in giving addicts without commitment a place in line with all low income persons.

And what about fairness to the community? What about the landlords and neighbouring tax payers stuck with the continual repair and security costs? What about the safety concerns of children, seniors and other more vulnerable people? What about loss of enjoyment along with depreciated economic values? What about policing the even less desirables who hang around and supply drugs to the housing facility? What about the loss of tax revenues from business displacement and devalued properties? What about the unrecoverable loss of healthy communities?

Housing First is a social experiment of extremely high risk. They hold high the ‘compassionate approach’ flag in its lobby as a non-profit venture. There is much more to it than a simple reduction in the number of people sleeping on the street.

There is already a high cost in dealing with the unpredictable behaviour of persons with untreated mental illness and/or addiction. A high concentration of people with risk behaviour issues amounts to institutional housing. It is the thin edge of a wedge that will lead to the establishment of a multitude of related social service providers. Housing First is a simplistic solution that will effectively multiply the problems of economic and social costs to the surrounding community.

It is urgent that you take a closer look at what is being sold here.

Housing First is an abandonment of well-reasoned efforts for more low income housing. It advocates priority to the homeless, with untreated mentally ill and unresolved drug/alcohol addiction issues. It is an abandonment of carrot/stick or reward/punishment as a motivating force in changing the lifestyle of those needing to make batter choices. It is a program for failure and, as such, it is not supportable.

The displacement of worthy residents, low income or otherwise, for a risky large scale social experiment such as this is totally unacceptable.

The best proven policy is one of ‘tough love:’ Proven treatment compliance first before long term housing support.

We all know the bad apple analogy. We should also understand the issue of enablement. Adoption of Housing First involves tacit approval and complicity in perpetuating antisocial or destructive behaviour. It provides comfort without obligation for positive change. Teaching people how to fish rather than providing them daily with free fish is a form of tough love. Certainly, helping people to make better choices involves much more than wishful thinking and free hand outs.

Ian R. Sisett, Kelowna

 

Just Posted

Traffic will be backed up leaving Kelowna

Plan your commute home strategically

Grass fire sparks near Kelowna’s UBCO campus

Construction workers in the area helped extinguish small fire, likely caused by lightning

Water quality advisory in Kelowna lifted

After a month of warnings, officials say testing shows water quality is good again

Progress made on Kelowna Visitor Centre

The centre is set to open mid summer

Kelowna names new city manger

City goes in-house and picks planning boss Doug Gilchrist to replacement Ron Mattiussi

Humans locked in for love at Kelowna Shelter

BC SPCA Lock-In for Love hopes to raise $25,000

Fireworks and fires over a half-metre banned Friday in Kamloops centre

B.C. Wildfire Service banning to category 2 and 3 fires in Kamloops Fire Centre at noon Friday

Rescued Oregon family simply unprepared for adventure, RCMP say

Agencies now helping the group of four get to their destination in Alaska

Large B.C. tree dies after possible poisoning

Police and District investigate after large chestnut tree’s rapid decline

Canucks release 2018-19 season schedule

Vancouver to face Calgary Flames on Wednesday, Oct. 3, for home opener

VIDEO: Luxury Home and Design Show opens with Italian flare

Event set to run Friday to Sunday at BC Place in Vancouver

Small new charge on BC Hydro bills goes toward new crisis fund

The new fund aims to help customers who find themselves in financial emergencies

UPDATED: Crown appeals B.C. polygamous leader’s acquittal in child bride case

James Oler had been charged with taking his underage daughter to the U.S. to marry her off

Fake cops ‘arrest’ woman, steal $6,000 in latest CRA scam

Vancouver police urge people not take calls from anyone saying they’re from the Canada Revenue Agency

Most Read