Letter: Leave farmers to manage their own water

Farmers collectively have proven more responsible in husbanding our precious water resources than urbanites and city parks.

To the editor:

Re: Proposed amalgamation of Kelowna’s water districts.

So MP Stephen Fuhr has joined our mayor (Kelowna mayor Colin Basran) in calling for the amalgamation of the five major water systems serving the Kelowna area, apparently to qualify for federal money.

While amalgamation has a certain appeal, I would urge caution by responsible authorities including Fuhr and Basran. Both express concern for urban water users but ignore legitimate interest of farmers.

Our water systems were initially created by and for our important farming industry. Their historic legal water rights supported investments in dams and distribution systems now worth hundreds of millions of dollars. The record shows that, despite their large water consumption, farmers collectively have proven more responsible in husbanding our precious water resources than urbanites and city parks.

Irrigation systems have been adapted to also serve our growing urban needs and it is this use that has led to demands for huge new investments in water treatment not required by farmers, so why should agriculture pay for treatment it does not need?

Amalgamation threatens confiscation of farmers, control over water rights, adding to their loss of rights under the ALR, further undermining an already endangered agricultural industry that remains the foundation of our economy and attraction to tourists.

Do we hear Mr. Fuhr and Mr. Basran offering compensation to our farmers?

We can already visualize a large new water bureaucracy with dozens of high salaried officials a la Interior Health, and no doubt a new highrise office building somewhere downtown. This will guarantee the support of both our bureaucrats and development community.

But instead of efficient and economic management by the water districts, we can guarantee that amalgamation will multiply operating costs to the detriment of both farmers and general taxpayers.

Is there a solution? Perhaps it is the physical separation of the domestic and agricultural water systems that would allow farmers to retain control of their vital irrigation needs and leave urbanites to fight the bureaucracy over water quality, costs and restrictions.

I would like to see a careful analysis of the costs and benefits of this alternative, which may prove to be more practical than at first glance.

Glen Wittur, Kelowna

 

Just Posted

Glenrosa residents asked to secure garbage

WildSafeB.C. issues warning about bears

UPDATE: Car engulfed in flames in Winfield

Firefighters were able to extinguish the burning car quickly

Kelowna boat retailers worry about tit-for-tat tariffs by U.S. and Canada

A 10 per cent tariff on new boats coming into Canada is prompting big cuts to boat orders

Used needle falls from sky in Vernon

A Vernon resident said a syringe fell out of the sky and landed at his feet

Lake Country Parents disturbed by song lyrics

The name of the song by a local musician is ‘Amber Alert’

VIDEO: Vernon-area students read for rank

RCMP visited JW Inglis on Wednesday as part of the Read with Me and the RCMP program.

New Jersey forward Taylor Hall wins Hart Trophy as NHL MVP

Vancouver’s Sedin brothers share King Clancy Award for humanitarian efforts

Unfiltered: IPAs explained with Cannery Brewing brewmaster

Checking out the new IPA created by Penticton brewery Cannery Brewing Company

Man gets 2 years in prison for assault on Okanagan Correctional officer

Union rep said inmate sucker punched correctional officer, continued assault after officer fell

50 new fires sparked in B.C. after lightning strikes across province

Similar conditions seen at the beginning of 2017 wildfire season

B.C. woman graduates high school at age 92

Nanaimo’s Joan Deebank the oldest high school graduate ever in B.C., as far as ministry can confirm

B.C. Appeal Court rules lottery winner must be paid back $600,000 loan

Enone Rosas won $4.1 million in a lottery in 2007 and loaned a portion to a friend

Liquor review finds issues with B.C. wholesale monopoly

Report calls for ‘conflict of interest’ in system to be fixed

VIDEO: Vernon-area students read for rank

RCMP visited JW Inglis on Wednesday as part of the Read with Me and the RCMP program.

Most Read