Letter: Speaking in favour of the speculation tax

Kelowna letter-writer says the reaction of city council is disappointing

To the editor:

I support the speculation tax for the city of Kelowna. As stated in Kelowna’s city staff report of March 2018, less than one percent of residential properties will be affected.

Kelowna is enduring a housing crisis. Many workers, students, and families are either living in overpriced, overcrowded rentals, or are leaving or not moving to Kelowna due to a housing shortage.

The tax poses a very minor risk to real estate sales; the estimate from city staff is between 50 and 75 condo unit sales will not occur as a result of the tax.

These condo units would, presumably, become homes for local residents. This sales projection does not, in any reasonable way, contribute to wild panic that a huge loss in construction jobs and tourism will result. The loss of 50 to 75 condos of tourists, who are here for less than a year, will not destroy our local economy. Locals, living here, making wages, and going for dinner, drinks, and golf 12 months a year will most certainly help our economy.

This tax, however, is not only an economic issue. It is a tax about values. I believe that owning two or more houses is a pleasant luxury. Living in one safe shelter is not a luxury. I believe that taxes on luxuries are not punitive. I believe taxes bring all earners into a just society. I pay more income tax now, as a professor, than I did when I worked in downtown Kelowna, in the early 90s, as a waitress. I am proud to pay taxes to support my community.

Some criticism of the tax cries out that wealthy people are being punished; that view of taxation does have some history, though I’m not sure it is a side of history the wealthy would like to align themselves with. Robin Hood was the good guy, you may recall.

I support this tax. I am extremely disappointed in my city and regional leadership for claiming they represent a united front against this tax.

I see no evidence that they sought out specific consultation with teachers, workers, or community groups. I also am disappointed at the lack of respect given to the report on this issue by the city of Kelowna’s own staff, whose work concludes that this tax will have minimal impact on the real estate market, but will contribute to solving the problem of homelessness.

Norah Bowman, Kelowna

To report a typo, email:
newstips@kelownacapnews.com
.


@KelownaCapNews
newstips@kelownacapnews.com

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Just Posted

Kelowna city council reverses itself on pot shop locations downtown

Council now says shops will be allowed on parts of Lawrence and Leon Avenues.

Kelowna RCMP turn to public to identify person of interest

RCMP has released a sketch of the man related to an alleged break and enter

Open burning permitted again in Kamloops Fire Centre

Low fire rating prompts decision throughout Kamloops Fire Centre

Incumbent trustee candidate reassesses SOGI 123 impact

Lee-Ann Tiede says mandated student inclusiveness program has some issues

West Kelowna candidates weigh in on how they’d like to see crime dealt with

This week learn about how your candidates feel about crime in West Kelowna

Weekday weather update

The rain moves in right across the Okanagan-Shuswap valley

Recent jump in U.S. butter imports? All smooth, says Canadian dairy farmers

U.S. farmers recently enjoyed extra access to the Canadian market

Potential replacements for Phoenix pay system to start testing soon: Brison

Testing of prototypes to replace troubled federal pay system will begin within weeks

Nanaimo’s Tilray Inc. briefly the world’s largest cannabis company

The company, only listed in the US, nearly reached $300 in afternoon trading on Wednesday

Woman who helped kidnap Elizabeth Smart released from prison

Smart was 14 years old when she was snatched from her Salt Lake City home in 2002 by street preacher Brian David Mitchell

New York books editor out after backlash over Jian Ghomeshi essay

Ian Buruma, who was appointed as editor of the New York Review of Books in late 2017, no longer works for the publication

B.C. couple plans sustainable, zero-waste life in the Shuswap

Plan includes building a tiny house before the snow flies

Housing slowdown forecast to cool B.C. economy

Conference Board says pipeline, trade uncertainty affecting investment

B.C. hockey product eyes shot at Olympic spot with China

Fletcher is one of 24 who travelled to Shenzhen, China for the first official Olympic dev camp.

Most Read