Letter: Trudeau’s actions badly misconstrued

One Kelowna reader weighs into the debate around Wilson-Raybould and SNC Lavalin

To the editor:

The SNC Lavalin affair is a highly emotional crisis marking the collision of important legal and ethical issues.

But these issues may be misunderstood.

The legal issues are simple—(former justice minister) Jody Wilson-Raybould acknowledged early on that the Prime Minister’s Office did nothing illegal.

The “pressure” that she found “inappropriate” did not prevent her from exercising her legal authority as attorney-general.

READ MORE: Trudeau says Wilson-Raybould, Philpott no longer Liberal caucus members

In short, no one tried to override her decision to prosecute SNC. When she was replaced as attorney general, the decision to replace her was legal because all cabinet ministers serve at the discretion of the prime minister.

When replaced, she surmised that the PMO wanted a new attorney-general who would reverse her SNC decision. If the new attorney general were to reverse her decision, that action would also be legal.

In short, Wilson-Raybould was 100 per cent correct in stating that nothing illegal was done.

Ethical issues are more complex. The great ethical issues typically involve the collision of two highly important ethical values.

One such value is the independence of prosecutorial decision-making. Another is the nation’s economic well-being.

Raybould has said, “This goes far beyond saving jobs.” She implies that the issue of job loss is somehow minor and illegitimate because it is political.

READ MORE: Wilson-Raybould no longer welcome in Liberal caucus

But Wilson-Raybould had the dual role of attorney general and minister of justice. In the latter role, she was an active member of a political team dedicated to considering public-affairs (i.e. political) issues.

As one law professor put it, the SNC affair is not a scandal but an ethical dilemma.

Prosecutorial independence is very important—thank God the PMO made no attempt to override it. And Canada’s economic well-being is also very important.

We now know that Trudeau was not fabricating his concern about job losses. SNC Lavalin had written to the government predicting big job losses and threatening to move its head office out of Canada.

READ MORE: Liberal-dominated justice committee ends SNC-Lavalin probe amid opposition howls

It would be outrageous had the prime minister chosen to ignore the economic consequences of prosecution.

Trudeau wanted not a violation of the law but “a solution” to a politico-legal dilemma.

One such solution might be to reduce the moratorium on federal contracts from 10 years to two or three years. This would be a politico-legal solution that would prevent not only SNC but any Canadian company from being crippled by criminal prosecution.

Wilson-Raybould has consistently and persistently elevated a single ethical value to superordinate importance.

Trudeau has acted as though he has an obligation to balance priorities in a way that is both legally and politically legitimate.

In my view, Trudeau’s actions have been badly misconstrued.

Gary Willis


Just Posted

‘Significant number’ of Kelowna rentals over 40 years old: report

From 2011 to 2016, 73 per cent of new households in Kelowna were rentals, according to the city

Fire in Kelowna apartment started in garbage can

The apartment was evacuated for a 4th-floor fire

Crane removal from downtown Kelowna to close streets

What goes up must come down and Ellis Street will be affected

Suspect restrained by bystanders after unprovoked assaults in West Kelowna

A 33-year-old Ontario man faces a number of potential charges

Car crashes into Kelowna business

Damages were done to the storefront of Interstate Batteries All Battery Centre on Banks Road

B.C. sockeye returns drop as official calls 2019 ‘extremely challenging’

Federal government says officials are seeing the same thing off Alaska and Washington state

Expanded support to help B.C. youth from care attend university still falling short

Inadequate support, limited awareness and eligibility restrictions some of the existing challenges

Ethnic media aim to help maintain boost in voting by new Canadians

Statistics Canada says new Canadians made up about one-fifth of the voting population in 2016

Cross-examination begins for B.C. dad accused of killing young daughters

Andrew Berry is charged in the deaths of six-year-old Chloe and four-year-old Aubrey in 2017

Dog attacked by river otters, Penticton owner says

Marie Fletcher says her dog was pulled underwater by four river otters in the Penticton Channel

Civil claim filed over motocross track west of Summerland

Track was constructed on agricultural land around 2016

BC SPCA overwhelmed with cats, kittens needing homes

Large number of cruelty investigations, plus normal ‘kitten season’ to blame

Car catches fire while being towed by motor home on Hwy. 97

The incident occured just north of Sage Mesa Rd., no injuries have been reported

Most Read