Letter: Vengence not served by harsh sentences

This focus on punishment reveals an obsession with inflicting torment upon wrongdoers, even if such penalties do nothing to reduce violence.

To the editor:

This is a hard letter to write.  It’s an emotional topic and I foresee it will be misconstrued as a lack of sympathy for victims of crime. It is really a plea for a less vengeful society.

It is very troubling to read about people’s obsession with punishment in the case of the murder of Caesar Rosales. In fact after almost every trial and sentencing, news articles focus on punishment and public outrage that the sentence wasn’t harsh enough.  This focus on punishment reveals an obsession with inflicting torment upon wrongdoers, even if such penalties do nothing to reduce violence.

In fact, harsh sentencing may encourage rather than deter violence. Incarceration, particularly without adequate health care, rehabilitative therapy, meaningful work, and protection from assault, is a form of violence. When the state condemns a person to death or long-term confinement in brutal conditions, it is announcing that vengeance is honorable, that violence is a legitimate response to injustice, and some lives are not redeemable. Destroy your enemy. In an economically insecure, profoundly unequal patriarchal and white supremacist society, this is a dangerous message.

Another assumption seems to be that sufficient vengeance will bring emotional closure. How can inflicting more torture on perpetrators and doing nothing to reduce the level of violence in society, thus increasing the chance that another person will be the victim of similar crime, bring ‘closure’?

Can we imagine a criminal justice system—restorative not retributive justice—where the imperative is not to punish bad people but to help all people become less violent? Can we imagine ‘public outrage’ because an offender was not afforded sufficient psychiatric care? Rather than punishment for its own sake, the primary goal of criminal justice should be the well-being of all involved—victim, perpetrator and other community members. The culture of punishment must give way to a culture of rehabilitation and healing.

This is already underway in some schools, with programs emphasizing dialogue and mediation over suspension and expulsion, seeing misbehaviour as an opportunity for teaching responsibility and self-worth. When young people internalize the principles of nonviolent conflict resolution rather than the punishment imperative, they are less likely to use violence against those who offend them. Less violent child-rearing and schooling and less tolerance of state-sanctioned violence are key components for the sweet dream of a less violent society. It’s that or build more prisons, expect more rapes, more wars, more barbarism. The future is up to us.

Mark Haley, Kelowna Peace Group member

 

Just Posted

Community Leader Awards: Anja Dumas

The Kelowna Capital News puts the spotlight on community leaders with annual awards

Sagmoen neighbours recall alleged hammer attack

Woman was screaming outside Maple Ridge townhouse in 2013

Blowing snow, slippery sections on Okanagan Connector

Compact snow, poor visibility on Highway 97 from Pennask Summitt to Brenda Mines.

IH adds immunization clinic Sunday in Kelowna

Drop-in meningococcal vaccination clinic on today at Community Health & Services Centre

Fire crews investigating oil sheen on Penticton Creek

Fire crews are working to contain the oil from spreading

REPLAY: B.C. this week in video

In case you missed it, here’s a look at replay-worthy highlights from across the province this week

Family suspends search for missing Alberta couple, plane near Revelstoke

Due to bad weather, families of missing Albertan couple say they will resume in the spring

Fire crews investigating oil sheen on Penticton Creek

Fire crews are working to contain the oil from spreading

UBCO prof tests software to help cancer patients

Program may help those reluctant to engage ‘tough conversations’ in advance care planning

Broken de-icer delays flights at Kelowna airport

Passengers were on board for three hours Sunday waiting for departure to Vancouver

Canadian grocers make $3M per year from penny-rounding: UBC study

Ottawa announced plans in 2012 to phase out the copper coin

Well-known Canadian bird making a comeback

Once on the brink of extinction, the peregrine falcon no longer considered at risk in Canada.

Suzuki: Shine a light during dark times

People need to remain positive despite difficult and unpredictable political climate

Most Read