Sleep it off in your car at own risk

We are all on side about how important it is to prevent drunk driving.

We are all on side about how important it is to prevent drunk driving.

Sure, there may be debates about what alcohol level is an appropriate threshold, whether it should be .05 or .08, but generally speaking, we all agree that drunk people should not be driving.

Equally, we are all on side that laws ought to operate fairly.

What about when those two values conflict?

Section 253(1)(a) of the Criminal Code prohibits having care or control of a motor vehicle while impaired.

Having care or control of a motor vehicle while impaired is just as criminal as actually driving a motor vehicle while impaired.

On first blush, that makes a lot of sense. We don’t want drunk people having care or control of motor vehicles.

I am going to offer you a scenario that might cause you to reconsider.

What if you are absolutely, fundamentally, totally against drunk driving to the point that you wouldn’t drive a car even if you had taken one sip from a beer.

You plan ahead to ensure that you have a designated driver or other transportation alternatives if you expect to be in circumstances when you might consume alcohol.

Friends invite you to a house party. You drive yourself to the party intending to take a cab home.

You call for a cab in the wee hours of the morning, when the bars are emptying out and cabs are scarce.

The hosts want to go to bed, and you are uncomfortable keeping them up for the hour you will have to wait for a cab.

You decide to wait in your car. It’s the middle of February, and it’s cold.  You start the engine to run the heater for a while.  You start to nod off, so you lay the seat back. You fall asleep.

An RCMP officer comes by before the cab gets there. Have you committed a criminal offence?

First of all, this is not a far-fetched scenario.

I happen to have a clear recollection of going to a “barn” party in Saskatchewan as a teenager and sleeping the night in my car because I had been drinking and I don’t think I’m unique.

I chose this column topic this week because a local fellow has recently

had his vehicle

impounded and his license suspended in similar circumstances.

I have also researched case law related to this issue and can tell you that many people have faced criminal charges in such scenarios.

Back to the question:  have you committed a criminal offence?

My answer is it depends.

Judges hearing these cases have interpreted the “care or control” offence as requiring a consideration of all relevant factors to determine the risk of danger arising from the possibility of intentionally or unintentionally setting the vehicle in motion, including the possibility that you might have changed your mind at some point, perhaps on the cab never arriving, and chosen to drive home.

I don’t like having to say “it depends” when it comes to whether or not certain conduct is criminal.

I also dislike the prospect of people being charged for criminal offences when they have no idea that what they are doing might be criminal.

Did you know that sleeping off alcohol impairment in your vehicle could result in a criminal conviction?

These dislikes of mine led to this column, to warn about the “care or control” provisions of the Criminal Code and hopefully prevent good people from unknowingly putting themselves in situations that could result in a criminal charge and conviction.

If you are interested in reading a recent judgment of the court considering this provision of the Criminal Code, email me and I will send it to you.

This column is intended to provide general information about injury claims.  It is not a substitute for retaining a DUI lawyer to provide legal advice specifically pertaining to your case. Paul Hergott is a lawyer at Hergott Law in West Kelowna.

paul@hlaw.ca

Just Posted

New multi-million baggage system up and running at YLW

Kelowna Airport’s $39 million outbound baggage system can handle 900 bags an hour

New safety doors aimto protect transit drivers

These new full-length doors will be tested in Victoria, Kelowna and Abbotsford

Death and fire not treated as suspicious

RCMP has turned the invesigation of Monday’s fire on Gaggin Road over to the BC Coroners Service

Reworked plan for Kelowna’s Green Square development approved

After rejecting first version of residential development expansion, council says yes to new plan

Police searching for GoPro owner

Police are looking for the owner of a GoPro seized by police in Kelowna

One person sent to hospital after fire near Keremeos

Fire ripped through a shed and Winnebego at Sunkatchers RV Park Co-operative

Two types of civic engagement in PIB

Some voted in the byelection, others protested the polls, as Penticton Indian Band fissures continue

‘Fresh eyes’ looking into three missing Cowichan Tribes men

First Nations want answers to their disappearances

Pedestrian hit moments after receiving safety reflector from police

The Vancouver Island man was treated for minor injuries by police at the scene

FortisBC LNG site exports first shipment of gas to China

The shipment is part of a pilot project that could see more exports in the future.

BC RCMP hunt for white SUV that rammed cruiser

Kamloops RCMP are looking for a white SUV headed north on the Yellowhead Highway

B.C. to reimburse methadone patients for taking clinic fees off welfare cheques

Provincial government agrees to pay back more than $5.5 million in deducted fees

Locket and brooch turned into RCMP

Kelowna - locket has been engraved with an undisclosed name

Lake Country bridge club supports those in need

Lake Country club challenges others to also donate money to the community

Most Read