Thiel: New study evaluates flu vaccine success

A study has concluded that the flu vaccine provided only moderate protection against influenza.

O n Nov. 6, the most comprehensive analysis of flu shot efficacy and efficiency was published in the British medical journal, The Lancet.

The authors concluded that the flu vaccine provided only moderate protection against influenza and in some years it made very little difference at all.

Dr. Michael Osterholm, director of the Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy at the University of Minnesota, stated that until now “no published meta-analysis has assessed the efficacy and effectiveness of licensed influenza vaccines in the USA with sensitivity and highly specific diagnostic test to confirm influenza.”

His study is, to date, the largest and most conclusive study on the matter. His research analyzed 5,707 articles published between 1967 and 2001.

In analyzing these thousands of studies for statistical significance and proper design, he found that only 31 studies effectively and appropriately measured the relationship between influenza vaccination and influenza.

He concluded that the great majority of studies, those that were disqualified from the study, vastly overestimated the health benefits of receiving influenza vaccine.

His meta-analysisfound that the vaccine was about 59% effective overall in individuals 18 to 65 years of age. In other words, more than 40% of individuals who receive the flu shot received no protection against the flu.

He further stated that an influenza vaccine ideally should be 85 to 95% effective for all ages to be considered a good vaccine.

Dr. Joseph Bresee, chief of the epidemiological and prevention branch and the National Centers for Disease Control’s Influenza Division, felt like a 59% estimate is appropriate.

Interesting enough, the CDC has downgraded the estimated effectiveness of influenza vaccine from 70 to 90% to 50 to 70%.

When analyzing study design and deeming whether or not it was appropriate or flawed, he found that “no such trials met inclusion criteria for children aged 2 to 17 years or adults 65 years or older.”

So in essence, Dr. Bresee is saying that there are no studies to date that have effectively looked at the effectiveness of the flu vaccine from the ages of 2 to 17 and 65 or older.

In his published, peer-reviewed study he states: “Every year, large-scale campaigns in many developed countries are undertaken to vaccinate all people aged 65 years or older to prevent serious illness and mortality.

“With an estimated 90% of all seasonal influenza related mortality occurring in this group, and effective intervention is an important public health priority. However, this is the age group for which we have the least data supporting the efficacy or effectiveness of influenza vaccines to reduce morbidity and mortality.

This article contains no less than 71 references and can be viewed online at The Lancet.

Just Posted

Tommy Chong says cannabis legalization makes him proud to be a Canadian

Legendary marijuana advocate and comedian celebrates cultural milestone at Kelowna event

West Kelowna candidates discuss new city hall

This week learn about how your candidates feel about a new city hall in West Kelowna

Science teachers converge on Kelowna for conference

Exposing new instructional classroom tools for science teachers

Okanagan competitors to be featured in arm wrestling documentary

Arm Nation, featuring competitions from Kelowna and Penticton, will air on Oct. 20 on APTN

Former Vernon man guilty of Japanese exchange student’s murder

Natsumi Kogawa was found at empty heritage mansion shortly after she was reported missing in 2016

Cough cough: Kelowna MLA gets flu shot to prep for the cold season

Steve Thomson got his flu shot from Lakeside Medicine Centre Friday

Watch it again: Kelowna mayoral candidates square off

Missing the LIVE Kelowna mayoral debate watch now

B.C. tickets win big in Lotto Max draw

Jackpot carried over; B.C. tickets share Max Millions prizes

‘Mom, I’m in trouble:’ Canadian faces 10 years for alleged graffiti

Brittney Schneider, another tourist caught spraying message on walls of Tha Pae Gate in Thailand

Feds consulting on national anti-racism strategy behind closed doors

Heritage Minister Pablo Rodriguez says people still face systemic racism in some communities

Black trucks figure prominently in Shuswap thefts

Chase RCMP investigating stolen vehicles from several communities

Enbridge aims for mid-November to finish B.C. pipeline repair after blast

A natural gas pipeline that ruptured and burned near Prince George caused an explosion and fireball

How to get government cheques if Canada Post staff go on strike

The Canadian Union of Postal Workers said members could go on rotating strikes as early as Monday

Most Read