Feds can keep border agency info secret in Chinese refugee-claim case

Feds can keep info secret in refugee case

OTTAWA — The federal government can keep a lid of secrecy on information a Chinese refugee claimant says could be vital to his case.

In a ruling made public Thursday, Federal Court Justice Simon Fothergill accepted the government’s plea to shield portions of two Canada Border Services Agency documents from disclosure in the case of Shiyuan Shen, who is wanted for alleged fraud in China.

The government had argued that revealing the protected information would hurt international relations and shatter Canada’s credibility in the eyes of foreign allies and sources.

Shen wanted to see full versions of the border agency documents, arguing they might help him show that evidence the government used to oppose his refugee claim was extracted through torture.

Shen also claimed the information under wraps was relevant to his allegations that the government breached its duty of candour and abused the process of the refugee board.

In his ruling, Fothergill said the shielded information “provides little, if any, additional evidence” of the matters Shen is pursuing. Even without the information, Shen’s lawyers are “well-positioned” to advance their arguments, he added.

While Fothergill found that elements of the federal argument about the need to keep the records secret “might be considered speculative,” he concluded release of the information would damage Canada’s international relations.

Shen left China in February 2002 and lived in the United States before arriving in Canada 10 years ago.

He married a Canadian and applied for permanent residence. However, the border services agency arrested him for suspected involvement in illegal activities in China related to the steel trade, based on an outstanding warrant issued by the Public Security Bureau in Shanghai.

In March 2011, Shen applied for refugee protection in Canada. At his refugee hearing, he argued the Crown was required to disclose all documents obtained from China related to his case.

Shen’s refugee application was rejected, and he challenged the decision. 

Federal authorities concede that more information should have been disclosed to Shen. But they refused to release the full contents of the two border services agency documents.

Instead, a public, redacted version of the information was provided to Shen. In addition, a version with more — but still not all — of the information was given to Shen’s lawyer, Lorne Waldman, and the refugee adjudicator, on condition that it be used solely in future refugee proceedings.

The portions that have been made public show Canada’s border agency looked at whether China’s Public Security Bureau had used torture to obtain information before it allowed a Shanghai police officer to testify at Shen’s refugee hearing.

The border agency also scrutinized Wei Huang’s history to see if he should even be allowed to enter Canada.

The agency concluded in October 2012 it was “possible” — but not likely — the evidence of the Shanghai Public Security Bureau officer was derived from torture.

“There are credible reports of mistreatment by the Shanghai police,” the border agency assessment says. But it adds there was “no evidence” that Shen’s unit, the economic crimes department, was known to rely on torture.

Ultimately, border agency officials decided Huang could testify in Shen’s case.

— Follow @JimBronskill on Twitter

Jim Bronskill, The Canadian Press

Canadian Press

Just Posted

(Contributed)
Collision slows rush hour traffic in Kelowna

Expect delays at K.L.O. Road and Richter Street on your commute Tuesday evening

A conceptual render of the proposed building at 955 Manhattan Drive. (Contributed)
Height not wanted on Kelowna’s Manhattan Drive

City staff said proposed five-storey building poses challenges

A for sale sign is shown in by new homes in Beckwith, Ont., just outside Ottawa, on Wednesday, Jan. 11, 2018. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
Thompson-Okanagan population grew despite COVID-19: report

The Chartered Professional Accountants of BC said there are 8,462 new residents in the region

Kelowna General Hospital. (File photo)
COVID-19 outbreak at Kelowna General Hospital declared over

Three people tested positive for the virus — two patients and one staff — one of whom died

A crash at the intersection of Harvey Avenue and Leckie Road on June 15. (Amandalina Letterio/Capital News)
Traffic stalled by Harvey Avenue crash in Kelowna

One lane is open as crews clean up after crash at Harvey Avenue and Leckie Road

People watch a car burn during a riot following game 7 of the NHL Stanley Cup final in downtown Vancouver, B.C., in this June 15, 2011 photo. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Geoff Howe
10 years ago: Where were you during the 2011 Vancouver Stanley Cup Riots?

Smashed-in storefronts, looting, garbage can fires and overturned cars some of the damage remembered today

Vernon-Monashee NDP MLA Harwinder Sandhu supported a motion in the B.C. legislature for Canada to create a national Indigenous History month Monday, June 13, 2021. (Contributed)
Canada needs a national Indigenous History Month, Vernon MLA agrees

Harwinder Sandhu supports motion to recognize June as month to advance reconciliation efforts with First Nations

Cannabis bought in British Columbia (Ashley Wadhwani/Black Press Media)
Is it time to start thinking about greener ways to package cannabis?

Packaging suppliers are still figuring eco-friendly and affordable packaging options that fit the mandates of Cannabis Regulations

(Facebook)
New trial date set for Penticton beach attacker’s triple assault charges

May trial was delayed after Crown witnesses failed to show up

Orange ribbons are tied to the fence outside Vernon’s Gateway Homeless Shelter on 33rd Street. (Jennifer Smith - Morning Star)
POLL: Low-key Canada Day in the works for Vernon

Councillor calling for Indigenous recognition for 2022

A conceptual design of Vernon’s new Active Living Centre, which will go to referendum Oct. 15, 2022. (Rendering)
Active living centre 2022 referendum planned in Vernon

City hoping to get Coldstream and Areas B and C back on board

Closure of the 2900 block of 30th Avenue will allow restaurants and other businesses to extend their patios onto the street. (Jennifer Smith - Morning Star)
Green light given to downtown Vernon road closure

Single block of 30th Avenue to close over summer months to boost business

Graduating Grade 12 student Savannah Lamb has been awarded an approximate $40,000 scholarship from the Beedie Luminaries foundation. (Contributed)
Dedicated Salmon Arm student earns scholarship to pursue post-secondary education

Savannah Lamb is graduating from Salmon Arm Secondary with a $40,000 scholarship

Most Read