A member of the Kelowna Yacht Club is suing the club claiming KYC officials are “fostering a culture of fear” that has negatively affected the value of his membership. (Capital News file)

Infighting at Kelowna Yacht Club makes it to court

Marc Whittemore, a local lawyer and prominent member of the club, filed a notice of civil claim Feb. 1

A member of the Kelowna Yacht Club is suing the organization for “fostering a culture of fear” that negatively affected the value of his membership.

Marc Whittemore, a local lawyer and prominent member of the club, filed a notice of civil claim Feb. 1 against the club and Don McEachern, the commodore.

The lawsuit shows plenty of infighting behind the scenes about how the club is run, who it’s run for and how members may complain. More specifically, it lays out a specific conflict between Whittemore and McEachern that escalated to a point that Whittemore claims caused him “embarrassment, humiliation and distress.”

Whittemore’s claim indicates he had long been dissatisfied with the way the club had been running and went to a members-only Facebook Page named, ‘the Dirty Burgees… a club,’ to air his grievances.

In a long comment where he brought up everything from the governance model to the path captains take to the board table, Whittemore said the club falls far below the expectations of a social club, pandering too much to non-members.

“Most members seem to have accepted the idea that KYC is a marina—a small parochial boating club and an off-season minor catering business—a far cry from a true year-round club,” he wrote. “It could be so much more with a fabulous vibrant social/dining membership to sustain the house year round.”

The comments made their way to the club’s board, which felt it was worth addressing through formal channels.

RELATED: Kelowna Yacht Club boat show

McEachern printed and published “falsely and with malice” a reprimand, according to the claim.

In the “reprimand” Whittemore was accused of making slanderous comments about the club and its executive director, contrary to club policy. The letter went on to say the comments were harassing, abusive, demeaning and vexations.

“It is requested that you immediately stop speaking ill of the club, the board or staff via any written means, including social media, unless it is a direct communication to our executive director or the board and retract the comments from all social media platforms,” read a portion of the letter.

Whittemore was also asked to apologize.

In the suit, Whittemore’s lawyer pointed out he was not the only one to complain about the club online, and he was signaled out. In turn, his lawyer formally contacted the club and asked that the letter be withdrawn and that his client get an apology.

He also pointed out that freedom of expression in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms trumps club rules about talking about the club.

RELATED: Yacht club to host blind fishing derby

A couple of months later, the club’s lawyer said it would remove the letter but no apology was forthcoming.

Whittemore’s suit was filed a few months after that.

It says Whittemore has “suffered embarrassment, humiliation, distress caused by the allegations contained in the reprimand, the prosecution thereof and threats of expulsion or suspension.”

“The plaintiff’s excellent reputation is tarnished by the issuance off the reprimand and allegations contained therein,” says the suit.

It adds: “As a result of the defendant’s high-handed treatment of members, including the plaintiff, who purport to criticize the club or the defendants, the defendant has thereby fostered a culture of fear which has negatively impacted the value of the plaintiffs membership and the plaintiffs use and enjoyment of the club.“

@carliberry_
carli.berry@kelownacapnews.com

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Just Posted

5-foot-long snake reported lost in Rutland

Buddy the snake is reported to be harmless and was reported missing May 22

Rockslide closes one southbound lane 2 km north of Summerland

DriveBC reported the slide just after 6:30 a.m.

Kelowna parents attend gang information session

Safer Schools Together trainers and former Hells Angel spoke to parents on May 22

RV trailer fire suppressed in West Kelowna late Thursday night

West Kelowna Fire Rescue aided BC Wildfire Services near Bear Creek Park

Okanagan-Shuswap weather: weekend rain

Environment Canada forecasts continuing bad weather for the start of the weekend

BREAKING: Court says B.C. can’t restrict oil shipments in key case for Trans Mountain

A five-judge Appeal Court panel agreed unanimously that B.C.’s proposed legislation was not constitutional

More than half of Canadians support ban on handguns, assault rifles: study

Divide between rural and urban respondents in latest Angus Reid Institute public opinion study

Last call for contestants in Teen Band Contest

Winners will play on stage at Penticton Peach Festival in August

Hope grows for Shuswap foodbanks thanks to modest volunteers

Secret garden donated 1,100 pounds of vegetables produced last year

Salmon Arm seeks to borrow $845,000 for Shuswap Regional Airport runway

Residents have until June 24 to voice opposition to bylaw

Spring rain needed as B.C. sees one of the lowest snowpack levels in 40 years

Snowpack levels in B.C. recorded on May 15 were similar to those in 2015 and 2016

Court to rule on B.C.’s pipeline permit law in crucial case for Trans Mountain

A panel of B.C. Court of Appeal judges has been mulling B.C.’s constitutional reference cas

Theresa May to quit as party leader June 7, sparking race for new PM

The new Conservative leader will become prime minister without the need for a general election

B.C. man who fell off cliff returns there to rescue eagle from vulture attack

Nanaimo’s James Farkas, who broke his hip in a fall, saves eagle on same beach months later

Most Read