Murder trial for former New Zealand councillor continues

Evidence for fainting equal to evidence of being pushed

A witness who offered testimony supporting the theory that Laura Letts-Beckett may had drowned after fainting told a Kelowna jury there was just as much evidence for the idea she was pushed into the water.

Dr. Matthew Orde, a forensic pathologist with the UBC Faculty of Medicine, was cross examined by Crown counsel Iain Currie Wednesday, as defence of the New Zealand politician charged with killing his wife continued.

In a report on the case, Orde detailed a number of reasons why Letts-Beckett may have died in the water Aug. 18, 2010, while boating with her husband Peter Beckett in remote Shelter Bay on Upper Arrow Lake.

Cold water shock — the process of someone gasping when they find themselves in cold water and sucking in cold water — was among the possibilities he listed.

“Do you have any evidence that cold water shock was a significant factor?” asked Currie.

“ No I don’t. I can simply raise it as an issue,” Orde replied.

“Given the available literature, if a jury were to conclude that the water was 20 C or above when Ms. Letts-Beckett went in the water, would you agree there would be there would not be a likelihood of cold water shock?” Currie asked.

Orde couldn’t support that theory definitively, so Currie asked him to translate what he did believe into “lay language.”

“Cold water shock is a thing — one. And two, it may or may not have happened here — yes?” said Currie.

Orde agreed to that.

Currie also challenged Orde’s theory that heart issues may have played a part in Letts-Beckett’s fall into the water. Part of the evidence in the background of that theory was that Letts-Beckett allegedly had told her husband, Peter Beckett, that her back hurt.

“If an otherwise healthy woman reportedly said her back was sore, out of 10, what mark would you give a first year medical student if they suggested the diagnosis of fatal arrhythmia?” Currie asked.

Orde pointed out that if she hadn’t died it clearly wouldn’t be a fatal condition, and said his job as a pathologist was to try and delve into any underlying factors that may have caused her to plunge in the water and ultimately die.

The back ache and potential arrhythmia fit into that category of thinking, he told the jury.

“Would you agree with me that sitting on a cooler on a thin cushion and a life-jacket would likely be uncomfortable?” Currie asked.

Orde said as a pathologist, he couldn’t answer that question but as a person he could imagine it would be uncomfortable.

Currie also pointed out that Letts-Beckett’s parents lived into their 80s and her siblings were alive well into their 40s and 50s without any evidence of a heart condition, which is a factor that should be considered when assigning potential heart health diagnoses to a person.

Ultimately, said Currie, there was no medical evidence that Letts-Beckett had an underlying cardiac condition. The same goes for the theory that she fainted and fell into the water.

“If Ms. Letts-Beckett was pushed into the water, you wouldn’t expect to find forensic evidence of that either?” said Currie.

“I would not,” said Orde.

“Yet you haven’t listed that possibility anywhere for the jury to consider as a possible contributory factor?” said Currie.

Currie later pointed out that there are many circumstances where a person falls in the water and doesn’t drown, not the least of which being when someone is nearby and reaches out to help someone onto a boat.

Beckett, now 60, denies murdering second wife Laura Letts-Beckett. He was arrested in August 2011 and charged with murder and Crown counsel is attempting to prove he killed her intending to claim on a life insurance policy he had taken out in her name.

Just Posted

Rock slide closes Hwy. 1 south of Ashcroft until Friday afternoon

A rock slide Thursday afternoon near Spences Bridge closed the highway in both directions

Penticton hospital fourth busiest in the region for opioid overdose

The highest was Kelowna General with about 355, followed by Vernon Jubilee 310 and Royal Inland in Kamloops with 180

Okanagan losing battle to preserve wetlands

Political will called for to create and enforce mitigation standards

West Kelowna water info to be included with utility bills

Changes coming for residents include increases to the rates they will pay for water from now on

Interior Health managers voice discontent

Negative comments about work culture aimed at CEO Chris Mazurkewich.

Kelowna’s Ursel to coach host team at Olympics

Bob Ursel is headed to the Olympics with South Korea’s national men’s curling team

Vernon homeless camp decommissioned

Camp off Highway 97 near 48th Avenue knocked down Thursday

OKM player grateful for show of sportsmanship

Emma Parmar, who suffered a knee injury prior to the season, was thankful for an opponent’s gesture.

Penticton organizer caught off-guard on NHL Young Stars comment

Penticton event chair said he cannot confirm or deny anything, just that an event will be held in the city

Kelowna choirs join forces with Vancouver for concert

Together We Breathe will be held at 3 p.m., Saturday, Jan. 27 at First United Church

WestJet appeals lost bid to scrap harassment lawsuit

Airline argues judge was wrong to have dismissed the company’s application to strike the legal action

Can U.S. border guards search your phone? Yes, and here’s how

Secretary of homeland security explains a new policy that let’s border guards check phones

‘Beautiful writer’ Nancy Richler dies of cancer in Vancouver hospital

Montreal-born author spent most of her adult life in B.C. as a fiction writer and novelist

B.C. commuters vote to rename bus service to ‘Jeff’

The company asked and the people of Facebook answered

Most Read