Hergott: Presumption of negligence when injured no sure thing

In the “no fault” world of Worksafe BC, a workplace injury is compensable regardless of how it occurs.

Consider this scenario: I slipped and fell, and was hurt. It happened in a store. Do I have a legal claim for compensation for my injuries and losses?

Paul HergottWhile it’s a clear, straight forward question, unfortunately there isn’t a clear, straight forward answer.

In the “no fault” world of Worksafe BC, a workplace injury is compensable regardless of how it occurs.

If you slip and fall in the course of your employment, it doesn’t matter how careful your employer had been to ensure a safe work place, nor how careless you might have been—you are entitled to benefits.

Unless you are in the course of employment, though, compensation for a “slip and fall” injury requires a finding of fault, or  negligence. Someone, besides you, has to have done something wrong to cause the fall to occur.

Isn’t it obvious, though? You slipped and fell. Clearly, the floor must have been slippery. Since the store is in charge of making sure the floor is safe to walk on, isn’t fault a foregone conclusion?

In a May 11, 2016, court decision, Dudas v. Ikea Ltd., provides a helpful discussion of this interesting area of the law.

Justice G. C. Weatherill at paragraph 32 of his decision provides a list of principles that includes this important one: “A presumption of negligence is not created by the fact the plaintiff was injured. The plaintiff must establish that some act or failure to act…resulted in his or her injury.”

How obvious a failure to act could there be?  The floor was slippery.  The store owners need to make sure that doesn’t happen.

Weatherill provides this further principle, which answers that point. Referring to store owners as “the occupier,” he wrote: “The duty of care…does not require the occupier to remove every possibility of danger—the test is one of reasonableness, not perfection.”

The injured plaintiff in the Dudas case had walked into an Ikea bathroom and entered one of the toilet stalls.

While she was in the stall, the floor area was mopped. She slipped and fell as she approached the sink to wash her hands.

Perhaps surprisingly to many of you, the court decision went against the plaintiff.

The plaintiff assumed, perhaps reasonably, that she had slipped on water, but she was unable to say that for certain.

After falling, while sitting on the floor, she did not notice any water on the floor and her clothing was dry.

In his written decision, Weatherill noted that it was the plaintiff’s evidence that several people came and left the washroom while she was in the stall.

“If she did slip on water, which she has not proven, the source could have been water splashed on the floor while any one of these people was washing their hands at the sink…the court is not entitled to resort to speculation when determining the cause of the plaintiff’s fall.”

The last point of his analysis is a clear caution that each of us has responsibility for our own safety:

“This incident took place in a ladies washroom. The potential for some dampness on the floor ought reasonably to have been expected by anyone using it. The mere presence of some water on the floor does not constitute an objectively unreasonable risk of harm.”.

It is dangerous, in my view, for the public to assume that the owners of commercial premises are subject to a standard of perfection when it comes to keeping their premises safe.

The higher your expectation that a commercial premises is perfectly safe, the less care you are likely to take for your own safety.

If you do slip and fall, and are hurt, be sure you are exceedingly careful to document the circumstances, including getting witness statements and taking photographs.

Then if the matter ever goes to trial, you will be able to prove exactly what it is you slipped on and hope to achieve fair compensation.

Just Posted

Kelowna families honour the dead by releasing butterflies

The Nicholson matriarchs release 33 butterflies

Carr’s Landing Art Tour showcases local talent

14th annual tour in Lake Country July 28-29 and Aug. 4-5

The Okanagan Croatian Club all smiles after World Cup loss

They say winning second place brought Croatia to the world stage

East Shuswap Road wildfire’s fire line being controlled

Firefighters saved an eagle’s nest and eaglets while controlling fire lines

REPLAY: B.C.’s best video this week

In case you missed it, here’s a look at replay-worthy highlights from across the province this week

Course veterans seize victory in Peach City Classic

The first place titles in this year’s triathlon belonged to returning competitors.

Vernon writers launch online workshop for teens, young adults

Storymakers’ Raise Your Voice workshop seeks to help women writers uncover and use voice

Former NHL goalie Ray Emery drowns in Lake Ontario

Police say the 35-year-old’s death appears to be a ‘case of misadventure’

Air quality statement warns of smoky air for Kamloops area

Environment ministry says area on north side of Thompson River may be affected by wildfire smoke

Pussy Riot claims on-field protest at World Cup final

Russian protest group claimed responsibility after four people ran onto field in police uniforms

Fans party on Montreal streets after French World Cup win

To city is home to nearly 57,000 French nationals

Your reviews: John Fogerty rocks the South Okanagan

Photos and reviews from fans in Penticton at John Fogerty’s concert in the SOEC

B.C. VIEWS: Making private health care illegal again

Adrian Dix battles to maintain Cuba-style medical monopoly

Most Read